Issue 10094: BMM: SBVR Structured English (bmm-ftf) Source: Inferware (Mr. John Hall, john.hall@modelsys.com johnhallms@hotmail.com) Nature: Uncategorized Issue Severity: Summary: I propose that the BMM Concepts Catalog as published by the BRG be replaced by an equivalent Concepts Catalog in SBVR Structured English. The advantage would be that the BMM could be directly used by SBVR tools, as well as being readable by business people. Proposal Suggestion from Andrew Watson was: · Produce the BMM Final Adopted Specification with the Concepts Catalog as published the BRG source document · Produce a BMM interim specification with the Concepts Catalog in SBVR Structured English · Ask for a vote from the BMM FTF to replace the BMM FAS with the interim specification, and handle issues against the interim specification Resolution: TBD Revised Text: See chapter 9 of the BMM First Interim Specification Also see attached notes on conversion of the BMM Concepts Catalog as in the source document to SBVR Structured English (BMM_SBVR_SE.doc). Disposition: Open Resolution: see dtc/2007-08-04 for details Revised Text: Actions taken: August 7, 2006: received issue January 15, 2008: closed issue Discussion: End of Annotations:===== propose that the BMM Concepts Catalog as published by the BRG be replaced by an equivalent Concepts Catalog in SBVR Structured English. The advantage would be that the BMM could be directly used by SBVR tools, as well as being readable by business people. Proposal Suggestion from Andrew Watson was: · Produce the BMM Final Adopted Specification with the Concepts Catalog as published the BRG source document · Produce a BMM interim specification with the Concepts Catalog in SBVR Structured English · Ask for a vote from the BMM FTF to replace the BMM FAS with the interim specification, and handle issues against the interim specification Resolution: TBD Revised Text: See chapter 9 of the BMM First Interim Specification Also see attached notes on conversion of the BMM Concepts Catalog as in the source document to SBVR Structured English (BMM_SBVR_SE.doc). Disposition: Open Date: Tue, 22 Aug 2006 13:46:46 +0100 From: John Hall Reply-To: john.hall@modelsys.com Organization: Model Systems User-Agent: Mozilla Thunderbird 1.0.7 (Windows/20050923) X-Accept-Language: en-us, en To: Juergen Boldt Cc: issues@omg.org, bmm-ftf@omg.org Subject: Re: issue 10094 -- BMM FTF issue Pete Rivett suggested that a decision to issue an interim specification should be separate from a decision to represent the BMM concepts catalog in SBVR Structures English. Accordingly, I propose a two-part vote: 1) The BMM concepts catalog as published in the FAS (dtc/06-08-02) should be replaced by an equivalent concepts catalog in SBVR structured English. The concepts catalog in SBVR SE, and some explanatory notes on the conversion, are attached. 2) If the BMM FTF votes in favor of proposal 1, an interim specification should be published, and issues resolved against this specification rather than the FAS. [Note: please ignore dtc/06-08-03 until this vote has been taken] Regards, John Juergen Boldt wrote: This is issue # 10094 From: John Hall BMM: SBVR Structured English I propose that the BMM Concepts Catalog as published by the BRG be replaced by an equivalent Concepts Catalog in SBVR Structured English. The advantage would be that the BMM could be directly used by SBVR tools, as well as being readable by business people. Proposal Suggestion from Andrew Watson was: · Produce the BMM Final Adopted Specification with the Concepts Catalog as published the BRG source document · Produce a BMM interim specification with the Concepts Catalog in SBVR Structured English · Ask for a vote from the BMM FTF to replace the BMM FAS with the interim specification, and handle issues against the interim specification Resolution: TBD Revised Text: See chapter 9 of the BMM First Interim Specification Also see attached notes on conversion of the BMM Concepts Catalog as in the source document to SBVR Structured English (BMM_SBVR_SE.doc). Disposition: Open Juergen Boldt Director, Member Services Object Management Group 140 Kendrick St Building A Suite 300 Needham, MA 02494 USA tel: +1 781 444 0404 x 132 fax: +1 781 444 0320 email: juergen@omg.org www.omg.org BMM_SBVR_ConCat.pdf