Issue 10376: uml.xsd schema file in ptc/2006-04-05 is not correctly generated (uml2-rtf) Source: Fujitsu (Mr. Tom Rutt, tom(at)coastin.com) Nature: Revision Severity: Critical Summary: New ISSUE on UML 2.1 Schema File Source: Tom Rutt (Fujitsu) Criticality: URGENT Problem Description: The UML 2.1 RTF Final report cites the following supporting documents: ptc/2006-04-02 Unified Modeling Language: Superstructure ptc/2006-04-03 Unified Modeling Language: Infrastructure ptc/2006-04-04 Unified Modeling Language: XMI specifications ptc/2006-04-05 Unified Modeling Language: XSD specifications The uml.xsd schema file in ptc/2006-04-05 (which is an informative document) is not correctly generated. In particular, several of the enum values specified in this schema have prefixes attached, which are not specified in the Meta Model. For example, the visibilityKind enumeration has its values improperly prefixed by the string “vis_” ( vis_public, vis_private …). This has caused interoperability problems with existing tools, since some of them have used the incorrectly generated xsd file for uml There is a need to post a corrected uml 2.1 schema on the document server. Also, the OMG document references for the supporting xmi and schema files are not up to date in the superstructure specification. Proposed Solution: Post properly generated schemas in a new UML 2.1 XSD Specification file on the server. Post an updated version of the UML 2.1 RTF report which refers to the correctly generated UML XSD specification file. The Document references cited in Annex G of the UML 2.1 superstructure spec should be corrected to point at the most up to date and correct specifications. Resolution: Revised Text: Actions taken: September 28, 2006: received issue Discussion: End of Annotations:===== te: Wed, 27 Sep 2006 22:55:45 -0700 From: Tom Rutt Reply-To: tom@coastin.com User-Agent: Thunderbird 1.5.0.7 (Windows/20060909) To: issues@omg.org, Andrew Watson CC: Tom Rutt , Juergen Boldt Subject: Text for New URGENT Issue on UML 2.1 Schema file errors The attached new issue is URGENT, in that there have already been interop problems with UML 2.1 XMI files since some tools have used the incorrect schema. ------------------- New ISSUE on UML 2.1 Schema File Source: Tom Rutt (Fujitsu) Criticality: URGENT Problem Description: The UML 2.1 RTF Final report cites the following supporting documents: ptc/2006-04-02 Unified Modeling Language: Superstructure ptc/2006-04-03 Unified Modeling Language: Infrastructure ptc/2006-04-04 Unified Modeling Language: XMI specifications ptc/2006-04-05 Unified Modeling Language: XSD specifications The uml.xsd schema file in ptc/2006-04-05 (which is an informative document) is not correctly generated. In particular, several of the enum values specified in this schema have prefixes attached, which are not specified in the Meta Model. For example, the visibilityKind enumeration has its values improperly prefixed by the string .vis_. ( vis_public, vis_private .). This has caused interoperability problems with existing tools, since some of them have used the incorrectly generated xsd file for uml There is a need to post a corrected uml 2.1 schema on the document server. Also, the OMG document references for the supporting xmi and schema files are not up to date in the superstructure specification. Proposed Solution: Post properly generated schemas in a new UML 2.1 XSD Specification file on the server. Post an updated version of the UML 2.1 RTF report which refers to the correctly generated UML XSD specification file. The Document references cited in Annex G of the UML 2.1 superstructure spec should be corrected to point at the most up to date and correct specifications. -- ---------------------------------------------------- Tom Rutt email: tom@coastin.com; trutt@us.fujitsu.com Tel: +1 732 801 5744 Fax: +1 732 774 5133