Issue 10829: Usage of "Element::ownedMember" (uml2-rtf)
Source: International Business Machines (Mr. Andreas Maier, maiera(at)de.ibm.com)
Nature: Clarification
Severity: Significant
Summary:  In the Superstructure spec 2.1.1, there are a few occurences where an
      association end "ownedMember" in metaclass "Element" is referenced.
      This should be changed to reference the end "ownedElement" instead.


      The places I found, are:
         "Class::nestedClassifier"
         "Enumeration::ownedLiteral"
         "DataType::ownedAttribute"
         "DataType::ownedOperation"


Resolution: According to the metamodel diagrams, {subsets ownedMember} would refer to the closest inherited ownedMember attribute which would be Namespace, not Element. For example, see figure 7.12.
Change all references of Element::ownedMember to Namespace::ownedMember.
Revised Text: In Superstructure:
In Section 7.3.7 Class, association nestedClassifier, change Element::ownedMember to Namespace::ownedMember.
In Section 7.3.11 DataType, association ownedAttribute, change Element::ownedMember to
Namespace::ownedMember.
In Section 7.3.11 DataType, association ownedOperation, change Element::ownedMember to Namespace::ownedMember.
In Section 7.3.16 Enumeration, association ownedLiteral, change Element::ownedMember to Namespace::ownedMember.
In InfrastructureLibrary:
In Section 11.6.1 DataType, association ownedAttribute, change Element::ownedMember to
Namespace::ownedMember. In Section 11.6.1 DataType, association ownedOperation, change Element::ownedMember to Namespace::ownedMember.
In Section 11.6.2 Enumeration, association ownedLiteral, change Element::ownedMember to Namespace::ownedMember.
Actions taken:
March 17, 2007: received issue
April 25, 2011: closed issue
Discussion: 

End of Annotations:=====
s is issue # 10829		From: Andreas Maier <MAIERA@de.ibm.com>

Usage of "Element::ownedMember"

 In the Superstructure spec 2.1.1, there are a few occurences where an
      association end "ownedMember" in metaclass "Element" is referenced.
      This should be changed to reference the end "ownedElement" instead.


      The places I found, are:
         "Class::nestedClassifier"
         "Enumeration::ownedLiteral"
         "DataType::ownedAttribute"
         "DataType::ownedOperation"

From: Steve Cook <Steve.Cook@microsoft.com>
To: "Jim Amsden (jamsden@us.ibm.com)" <jamsden@us.ibm.com>
CC: "uml2-rtf@omg.org" <uml2-rtf@omg.org>
Subject: Resolution of 10829 in Ballot 5
Thread-Topic: Resolution of 10829 in Ballot 5
Thread-Index: Acq/vOI+jhBS8r/YRj6I/awBP0j7wg==
Date: Tue, 9 Mar 2010 19:18:17 +0000
Accept-Language: en-GB, en-US
X-MS-Has-Attach: 
X-MS-TNEF-Correlator: 


Jim

 

Resolution 10829 contradicts resolution 9375.

 

10829 says change .Element::ownedMember. to .Element::ownedElement..

9375 says change .Element::ownedMember. to .Namespace::ownedMember..

 

Both referring to 7.3.7.

 

Also, in 10829, is the correct resolution Element::ownedElement or Namespace::ownedMember (or both)?

 

-- Steve