Issue 11037: Clarify interoperability requirement 8.4.2.3.3                                                                                                                                                          (dds-interop-ftf)
Source: Real-Time Innovations (Mr. Kenneth Brophy, ken@rti.com ken.brophy@rti.com)
Nature: Uncategorized Issue
Severity: 
Summary: Source:
Real-Time Innovations, Inc. (Ken Brophy, ken@rti.com)
Summary:
The requirement contained in Section 8.4.2.3.3 is too restrictive and doesn't specify when resources can be reclaimed. If all Readers have acknowledged a sample, the Writer should be allowed to reclaim that sample's resources. Also, if a Reader NACKs a sample it has already ACKed, and the Writer is still able to provide a repair, it should.
Resolution:
Allow Writer to reclaim resources and send repairs if possible.
Revised Text:
Add the paragraph to the end of Section 8.4.2.3.3:

Once a Writer has received positive acknowledgement from all Readers, the Writer can reclaim any associated resources. However, if a Writer receives a negative acknowledgement to a previously positively acknowledged sample, and the Writer can still service the request, the Writer should send the sample.

Resolution: see above
Revised Text: Add the paragraph to the end of Section 8.4.2.3.3:

Once a Writer has received positive acknowledgement from all Readers, the Writer can reclaim any associated resources. However, if a Writer receives a negative acknowledgement to a previously positively acknowledged sample, and the Writer can still service the request, the Writer should send the sample.

Actions taken:
May 23, 2007: received issue
November 7, 2007: closed issue
Discussion: 
Resolution:
Allow Writer to reclaim resources and send repairs if possible.

End of Annotations:=====
s is issue # 11037

Clarify interoperability requirement 8.4.2.3.3

Source:
Real-Time Innovations, Inc. (Ken Brophy, ken@rti.com)
Summary:
The requirement contained in Section 8.4.2.3.3 is too restrictive and doesn't specify when resources can be reclaimed. If all Readers have acknowledged a sample, the Writer should be allowed to reclaim that sample's resources. Also, if a Reader NACKs a sample it has already ACKed, and the Writer is still able to provide a repair, it should.
Resolution:
Allow Writer to reclaim resources and send repairs if possible.
Revised Text:
Add the paragraph to the end of Section 8.4.2.3.3:

Once a Writer has received positive acknowledgement from all Readers, the Writer can reclaim any associated resources. However, if a Writer receives a negative acknowledgement to a previously positively acknowledged sample, and the Writer can still service the request, the Writer should send the sample.