Issue 11110: FINALIZED in LifeCycleState                                                                                                                                                                             (rtc-ftf)
Source: Technologic Arts (Mr. Takeshi Sakamoto, tsakamoto@tech-arts.co.jp)
Nature: 
Severity: Minor
Summary: Originally, LifeCycleState has FINALIZED attribute. I think that FINALIZED is not necessary. Because FINALIZED is compatible with Final state of statemachine. (I think that it cannot transit from FINALIZED to other states.)

In some language (such as Java), it is possible to call LightweightRTObject::finalize on the object and still have a valid object reference. But I think that it depends on implementation in PSM level. So I think that FINALIZED in LifeCycleState is not necessary in PIM level.
Resolution: Remove the FINALIZED in LifeCycleState.
Revised Text: n section 7.2.2.1, lightweightRTComponent, Figure7.3, Lightweight RTC M1 Illustration (This figure was added by the resolution to Isuue 10477), remove the attribute "FINALIZED" from LifeCycleState. (Note that the LifeCycleState have been added as Enumeration by the resolution to issue 10477.)
·	Remove the "FINALIZED" row from the attributes table in section 7.2.2.4, LifeCycleState.
·	Remove section 7.2.2.4.5 FINALIZED.
·	In RTC.idl and in Annex A, remove the FINALIZED member from the definition of enum LifeCycleState.

Actions taken:
July 2, 2007: received issue
January 15, 2008: closed issue
Discussion: 

End of Annotations:=====
s is issue # 11110

FINALIZED in LifeCycleState

Originally, LifeCycleState has FINALIZED attribute. I think that FINALIZED is not necessary. Because FINALIZED is compatible with Final state of statemachine. (I think that it cannot transit from FINALIZED to other states.)

In some language (such as Java), it is possible to call LightweightRTObject::finalize on the object and still have a valid object reference. But I think that it depends on implementation in PSM level. So I think that FINALIZED in LifeCycleState is not necessary in PIM level.