Issue 11182: 10.4: use of 'author' is redundant (kdm-rtf) Source: Adaptive (Mr. Pete Rivett, pete.rivett@adaptive.com) Nature: Uncategorized Issue Severity: Summary: 10.4: XMI already has the ability to capture the tool creating an instance: use of 'author' for this is redundant Resolution: Deferred to next RTF to allow more discussion Revised Text: Actions taken: July 23, 2007: received issue Discussion: End of Annotations:===== s is issue # 11182 10.4: use of 'author' is redundant Subject: RE: [BMM] Ballot 3 - EOB 30-Aug-07 Date: Wed, 29 Aug 2007 12:54:29 -0700 X-MS-Has-Attach: X-MS-TNEF-Correlator: Thread-Topic: [BMM] Ballot 3 - EOB 30-Aug-07 Thread-Index: AcfqYJCAt3tKviD5QyGBEKz6vJ7g0AAE4u7Q From: "Pete Rivett" To: "John Hall" Cc: "BMM FTF" I did not have the role names to comment on in the last draft I saw. For 11182 I'd like to see the following changes: a) observe the UML/MOF convention that roles/association ends start with lower case (as opposed to associations which start with upper case) b) for FormulatedCourseOfAction I'd prefer derivedCourseOfAction c) for ElementOfGovernance I'd prefer governingDirective d) for DeliveryMission I'd prefer deliveredMision (is the former a typo?) e) for MakingOrganizationUnit I'd prefer assessingOrganizationUnit f) not sure at all about 'determining' - why not 'guiding' or 'driving' e.g. Strategy guides organization unit guidingStrategy guidedOrganizationUnit g) not sure about 'component' since it's generally an overloaded term why not 'strategy is part of plan for mission' missionPart Pete -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- From: John Hall [mailto:johnhallms@hotmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, August 29, 2007 6:16 PM To: BMM FTF Subject: [BMM] Ballot 3 - EOB 30-Aug-07 Hello all, These two issues (two parts of the same requirement) have been under discussion for a long time, and several drafts have been circulated. The only comments I had in response to yesterday.s request were from Pete Rivettand Andy Evans, and I have incorporated them. Could you, please, vote by EOB 30 August 2007 on: Issue 10090: Base UML association names on fact type representations in the Concepts Catalog Yes [ ] No[ ] Abstain [ ] Issue 11282: Base UML role names on terms and verbs used in fact type representations in the Concepts Catalog Yes [ ] No[ ] Abstain [ ] Voting members are: 88solutions, Manfred Koethe Adaptive, Pete Rivett Business Rule Solutions, Ron Ross Business Semantics Ltd, Donald Chapin Deere & Company, Duane Clarkson EDS, Fred Cummins Fair, Isaac, James Taylor Inferware, Allan Kolber KnowGravity, Markus Schacher MEGA International, Antoine Lonjon Model Driven Solutions, Cory Casanave NIST , Ed Barkmeyer Neumont University, Tony Morgan No Magic, Bobbin Teegarden Pegasystems, John Pellant Rule ML Initiative, Said Tabet TIBCO, Paul Vincent Unisys, David Bridgeland Thanks, John 10.4: XMI already has the ability to capture the tool creating an instance: use of 'author' for this is redundant