Issue 11193: Section: Part III/BPMM - Informative Content page 139 (bpmm-ftf) Source: International Business Machines (Mr. Leo Roomets, roomets@us.ibm.com) Nature: Clarification Severity: Minor Summary: Question about SP9 Review Business Activities: “Review business activities” page 139 does not include any references to “development” as part of a product or service business activity. Only when you reach the configuration management section are there any references to development. i.e. on Page 179 Examples of configuration management control levels include - development control — configuration items that are being developed, prepared, or revised and that are under the control of the individuals performing the development, preparation, or revision….. and again for example on page 244 The reason for this process area at maturity level 3 is that control of the content of configuration items (critical work products) and CM product baselines are essential to support the end-to-end preparation, deployment, operation, supporting, and management of the organization’s products and services. Does OMG’s definition of preparation include development? Resolution: Agree with the issue. Resolution of this issue require changes to be made in a number of places in the BPMM - for consistency, not just in the places identified. And there are variants such as changing "preparing" to "developing and preparing." Revised Text: In the following table, the Current Text is a search string on the indicated page. Page # Current Text Change To vii preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 24 prepare, deploy, develop, prepare, deploy, 34 preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 36 prepare, deploy, develop, prepare, deploy, 42 prepares develops and prepares 49 preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 53 preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 65 preparation (requirements and construction), deployment, development, preparation, deployment, 69 preparation, deployment, development, preparation, deployment, 74 prepare, deploy, develop, prepare, deploy, 75 (sect 10.3.3 para 1) preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 75 (para 5) preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 76 (para 2) preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 76 (2nd bullet) preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 81 prepare, deploy, develop, prepare, deploy, 82 (para 1) prepare, deploy, develop, prepare, deploy, 82 (para 5) preparing the developing and preparing the 83 preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 85 preparation, deployment, development, preparation, deployment, 89 (sect 12.5, para 1) preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 90 (item3) preparation, deployment, development, preparation, deployment, 90 (item 4) preparation, deployment, development, preparation, deployment, 90 (item 5) preparation, deployment, development, preparation, deployment, 121-122: Sect SP 3 - (6 instances) prepare, deploy, develop, prepare, deploy, 122 - item 5 preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 123 preparing or deploying developing, preparing, or deploying 125 preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 126 (3 instances) preparation, deployment, development, preparation, deployment, 161 (2 instances) preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 193 preparation and delivery development, preparation, and delivery 204 preparing and delivering developing, preparing, and delivering 204 prepared and prior to delivery developed and prepared and prior to delivery 209 preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 213 (2 instances) preparing a product developing and preparing a product 213 preparing the products and services developing and preparing the products and services 220 preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 233 prepare, deploy, develop, prepare, deploy, 233 preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 234 prepare, deploy, develop, prepare, deploy, 245 preparation, deployment, development, preparation, deployment, 258 preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 274 preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 274 preparation, deployment, development, preparation, deployment, 277 preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 281 preparation of the offering development and preparation of the offering 287 prepare, deploy, develop, prepare, deploy, 291 prepares the offering develops and prepares the offering 291 preparation (including development and preparation (including 292 preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 292 designing and constructing designing, developing, and constructing 292 the preparing the products and services developing and preparing the products and services 292 the preparation of a product and service the development and preparation of a product and service 292 preparing a product and service developing and preparing a product and service 293 designed, constructed, and documented designed, developed, constructed, and documented 295 preparation, deployment, development, preparation, deployment, 296 prepared, deployed, developed, prepared, deployed, 303 preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 304 - preparation - development- preparation 306 offering preparation offering development and preparation 306 design and construction design, development, and construction 313 offering preparation and support offering development, preparation, and support 314 preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 323 offering preparation and support offering development, preparation, and support 324 preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 332 offering preparation and operations offering development, preparation, and operations 318 preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 343 preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 344 (2 instances) preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 374 preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 392 preparation, deployment, development, preparation, deployment, 416 preparing the complete improvement developing and preparing the complete improvement 421 prepared and evaluated developed, prepared, and evaluated 421 preparing and evaluating developing, preparing, and evaluating 421 (2 instances) preparation and evaluation development, preparation, and evaluation 422 preparation and evaluation development, preparation, and evaluation 422 preparation, evaluation, and deployment development, preparation, evaluation, and deployment 460 prepared in standard format developed and packaged in standard format 470 preparing, deploying, developing, preparing, deploying, 474 preparing, maintaining, developing, preparing, maintaining, 474 develop, maintain, develop, prepare, maintain, 477 preparing, maintaining, developing, preparing, maintaining, Actions taken: July 23, 2007: received issue April 15, 2008: closed issue Discussion: End of Annotations:===== m: webmaster@omg.org Date: 23 Jul 2007 13:36:05 -0400 To: Subject: Issue/Bug Report -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Name: Leo Roomets Company: IBM mailFrom: roomets@us.ibm.com Notification: Yes Specification: Business Process Maturity Model Section: Part III/BPMM - Informative Content FormalNumber: bmi/07-03-04 Version: 3 RevisionDate: 03/05/2007 Page: 139 Nature: Clarification Severity: Minor HTTP User Agent: Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SV1; .NET CLR 1.1.4322; .NET CLR 2.0.50727) Description Question about SP9 Review Business Activities: .Review business activities. page 139 does not include any references to .development. as part of a product or service business activity. Only when you reach the configuration management section are there any references to development. i.e. on Page 179 Examples of configuration management control levels include - development control . configuration items that are being developed, prepared, or revised and that are under the control of the individuals performing the development, preparation, or revision... and again for example on page 244 The reason for this process area at maturity level 3 is that control of the content of configuration items (critical work products) and CM product baselines are essential to support the end-to-end preparation, deployment, operation, supporting, and management of the organization.s products and services. Does OMG.s definition of preparation include development?