Issue 11687: Section: 4.1.9 SOAP Binding (corbawsdl-rtf)
Source:  (, )
Nature: Enhancement
Severity: Critical
Summary: The binding of CORBA System exception is not complete , regarding WSDL 1.1 (see http://www.w3.org/TR/wsdl#_soap:fault Each occurrence of : <fault name="CORBA.SystemException"/> must be replaced by : <fault name="CORBA.SystemException"/> <soap:fault name="CORBA.SystemException" use="literal"/> </fault> More details on http://rt.cpan.org/Ticket/Display.html?id=30893

Resolution: 
Revised Text: 
Actions taken:
November 26, 2007: received issue
Discussion: 

End of Annotations:=====

m: webmaster@omg.org
Date: 26 Nov 2007 12:10:31 -0500
To: <issues@omg.org>
Subject: Issue/Bug Report



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Name: Francois Perrad
Company: cpan
mailFrom: francois.perrad@gadz.org
Notification: Yes
Specification: CORBA to WSDL/SOAP Interworking Specification
Section: 4.1.9 SOAP Binding
FormalNumber: 06-11-01
Version: 1.2
RevisionDate: 11/01/2006
Page: 27
Nature: Enhancement
Severity: Significant
HTTP User Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.0; en-US; rv:1.8.1.9) Gecko/20071025 Firefox/2.0.0.9
Description
The binding of CORBA System exception is not complete , regarding WSDL 1.1 (see http://www.w3.org/TR/wsdl#_soap:fault Each occurrence of : <fault name="CORBA.SystemException"/> must be replaced by : <fault name="CORBA.SystemException"/> <soap:fault name="CORBA.SystemException" use="literal"/> </fault> More details on http://rt.cpan.org/Ticket/Display.html?id=30893


Date: Fri, 14 Dec 2007 14:37:17 -0500
From: Tom Rutt <tom@coastin.com>
Reply-To: tom@coastin.com
User-Agent: Thunderbird 1.5.0.13 (Windows/20070809)
To: Andrew Watson <andrew@omg.org>
Cc: ab@omg.org, francois.perrad@gadz.org, OMG Mars <mars@omg.org>
Subject: CORBA to WSDL Issue


Recently, Issue 11687 has been raised against the Corba to WSDL Interworking Spec.


There is no current RTF for this spec, and it is critical that this issue be resolve in an expedient manner.


The proposed solution by the Issue submitter is also incorrect.


It is important that the correct solution is progressed quickly to resolve this issue.


The following text includes a revision proposal which is correct, according to the WSDL 1.1 specification.


I would propose that OMG process this as an URGENT Issue resolution, to be processed by the Architecture Board.


-------------------
Issue 11687: Section: 4.1.9 SOAP Binding (corbawsdl-rtf)
Click here for this issue's archive. http://www.omg.org/issues/issue11687.txt
Nature: Enhancement
Severity: Significant
Summary:
The binding of CORBA System exception is not complete , regarding WSDL 1.1 (see http://www.w3.org/TR/wsdl#_soap:fault Each occurrence of:
"<fault name="CORBA.SystemException"/>"
must be replaced by:
"<soap:fault name="CORBA.SystemException"/> "


More details on http://rt.cpan.org/Ticket/Display.html?id=30893
Discussion:
The issue is pointing out a serious problem in the existing specification;
however the proposed resolution from the issue submitter is also incorrect.


One of the reasons this error was not detected earlier was that the SOAP binding elements are
expressed using the WSDL 1.1 extension mechanism, which is based on the .Any. type of XSD schema.
So this error cannot be detected by a simple XSD schema syntactic check.


It is very important to quickly resolve this issue, so the users of the spec can apply the
correct solution to their implementations.
Resolution:
Quoting from WSDL 1.1 (http://www.w3.org/TR/2001/NOTE-wsdl-20010315)
"
3.6 soap:fault


The soap:fault element specifies the contents of the contents of the SOAP Fault Details element.
It is patterned after the soap:body element (see section 3.5).


<definitions .... >
<binding .... >
<operation .... >
<fault>*
<soap:fault name="nmtoken" use="literal|encoded"
encodingStyle="uri-list"? namespace="uri"?>
</fault>
</operation>
</binding>
</definitions>


The name attribute relates the soap:fault to the wsdl:fault defined for the operation.


The fault message MUST have a single part. The use, encodingStyle and namespace attributes
are all used in the same way as with soap:body (see section 3.5), only style="document" is
assumed since faults do not contain parameters.
"


The revised text needs to comply with this section of WSDL 1.1.
Revised Text:
Replace each occurrence of:
"
<fault name="CORBA.SystemException" />
"
with:
"
<fault>
<soap:fault name="CORBA.SystemException" use="literal"/> "
<fault/>
"
Actions taken:



-- 
----------------------------------------------------
Tom Rutt        email: tom@coastin.com; trutt@us.fujitsu.com
Tel: +1 732 801 5744          Fax: +1 732 774 5133




Date: Fri, 1 Feb 2008 17:14:38 +0000
To: ab@omg.org
From: Andrew Watson <andrew@omg.org>
Subject: Issue 11687 now declared Urgent


Dear Architecture Board members,


I'm formally declaring issue 11687 as Urgent in accordance with the
procedure laid out in section 4.4.1.5 of the P&P (pp/07-08-01).


The summary of this issue can be found in the attachment (supplied by Tom
Rutt).


This is an issue with the CORBA/WSDL specification. However, since there is
currently no CORBA/WSDL RTF, this resolution will be voted by the
Architecture Board.


The default resolution will be to apply the change shown below.  Note that
this is NOT the proposed resolution in the attachment, which contains a
superfluous quote character.


The deadline for resolving this issue is 1700 GMT on 15th February 2008. I
will decide how to resolve the issue if and only if the AB fails to do so
by that time.


Please reply with EITHER your vote on applying this resolution OR your
suggestion for an alternative resolution (if any).


                                 Thanks,


                                    Andrew



Default Resolution
==================



Replace each occurrence of:


  "
    <fault name="CORBA.SystemException"/>
  "
with:
  "
    <fault>
       <soap:fault name="CORBA.SystemException" use="literal"/>
    </fault>
  "



Date: Tue, 5 Aug 2008 15:54:43 +0100
To: smsc@omg.org
From: Andrew Watson <andrew@omg.org>
Subject: Urgent Issue 11687 on CORBA/WSDL 1.2 specification
Cc: Linda Heaton <linda@omg.org>


Dear SMSC members,


This is to let you know that the Urgent resolution of Issue 11687 is being
applied to the CORBA/WSDL 1.2 specification (formal-06-11-01).


In the absence of a CORBA/WSDL RTF, this issue was voted on by the AB back
in February, but because of an oversight on my part, Linda wasn't informed
at the time. I corrected this yesterday, and she has now produced the
CORBA/WSDL 1.2.1 revision, which is being published today.


For your reference, the Urgent Issue declaration and ballot is attached below.


                                Thanks,


                                    Andrew


Dear Architecture Board members,


I'm formally declaring issue 11687 as Urgent in accordance with the
procedure laid out in section 4.4.1.5 of the P&P (pp/07-08-01).


The summary of this issue can be found in the attachment (supplied by Tom
Rutt).


This is an issue with the CORBA/WSDL specification. However, since there is
currently no CORBA/WSDL RTF, this resolution will be voted by the
Architecture Board.


The default resolution will be to apply the change shown below.  Note that
this is NOT the proposed resolution in the attachment, which contains a
superfluous quote character.


The deadline for resolving this issue is 1700 GMT on 15th February 2008. I
will decide how to resolve the issue if and only if the AB fails to do so
by that time.


Please reply with EITHER your vote on applying this resolution OR your
suggestion for an alternative resolution (if any).


                                 Thanks,


                                    Andrew



Default Resolution
==================



Replace each occurrence of:


  "
    <fault name="CORBA.SystemException"/>
  "
with:
  "
    <fault>
       <soap:fault name="CORBA.SystemException" use="literal"/>
    </fault>
  "