Issue 12154: Annex B / Figure B.38 (sysml-rtf) Source: No Magic, Inc. (Dr. Darren R.C. Kelly, nobody) Nature: Revision Severity: Minor Summary: Figure B.38: property names of p:[PowerSubsystem] inconsistent w.r.t. other figures Figure B.38 gives p:[PowerSubsystem] with parts: em: [ElectricMotor] t: [Transmission] ice: [InternalCombustionEngine] Figure 9.3 shows PowerSubsystem with parts: trsm: Transmission ice: InternalCombustionEngine (ecu:PowerControlUnit) (epc: ElectricalPowerController) Figure 9.6 IBD shows PowerSubsystem with parts: trsm: Transmission ice: InternalCombustionEngine (ecu:PowerControlUnit) (epc: ElectricalPowerController) Figure 15.10 IBD shows PowerSubsystem with parts: trsm: Transmission ice: InternalCombustionEngine emg:ElectricalMotorGenerator (ecu:PowerControlUnit) (epc: ElectricalPowerController) (can:CAN_Bus) Figure B.18 BDD shows PowerSubsystem with parts: trsm: Transmission ice: InternalCombustionEngine em: ElectricalMotorGenerator pcu:PowerControlUnit (epc: ElectricalPowerController) .. For consistency Figure B.38 should show p:[PowerSubsystem] with parts: emg: [ElectricMotor] (not 'em') trsm: [Transmission] (not 't') ice: [InternalCombustionEngine] Also, Figure B.18 should show PowerSubsystem with part: ecu:PowerControlUnit Visit also analysis at: http://school.nomagicasia.com/node/149 Resolution: Defer Postponed to the next RTF Revised Text: Actions taken: January 2, 2008: received issue January 3, 2017: Deferred April 6, 2017: closed issue Discussion: Discussion: This issue is deferred because no other proposed resolution was voted on during the schedule of the SysML 1.2 RTF. Disposition: Deferred End of Annotations:===== m: webmaster@omg.org Date: 02 Jan 2008 21:52:20 -0500 To: Subject: Issue/Bug Report -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Name: Darren Kelly Company: No Magic mailFrom: drdarrenkelly@nomagicasia.com Notification: Yes Specification: SysML1.0 Section: Annex B / Figure B.38 FormalNumber: formal/2007-09-01 Version: 1.0 RevisionDate: 09/01/2007 Page: 210 Nature: Revision Severity: Minor HTTP User Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; U; Linux i686; en-GB; rv:1.8.1) Gecko/20061023 SUSE/2.0-30 Firefox/2.0 Description Figure B.38: property names of p:[PowerSubsystem] inconsistent w.r.t. other figures Figure B.38 gives p:[PowerSubsystem] with parts: em: [ElectricMotor] t: [Transmission] ice: [InternalCombustionEngine] Figure 9.3 shows PowerSubsystem with parts: trsm: Transmission ice: InternalCombustionEngine (ecu:PowerControlUnit) (epc: ElectricalPowerController) Figure 9.6 IBD shows PowerSubsystem with parts: trsm: Transmission ice: InternalCombustionEngine (ecu:PowerControlUnit) (epc: ElectricalPowerController) Figure 15.10 IBD shows PowerSubsystem with parts: trsm: Transmission ice: InternalCombustionEngine emg:ElectricalMotorGenerator (ecu:PowerControlUnit) (epc: ElectricalPowerController) (can:CAN_Bus) Figure B.18 BDD shows PowerSubsystem with parts: trsm: Transmission ice: InternalCombustionEngine em: ElectricalMotorGenerator pcu:PowerControlUnit (epc: ElectricalPowerController) .. For consistency Figure B.38 should show p:[PowerSubsystem] with parts: emg: [ElectricMotor] (not 'em') trsm: [Transmission] (not 't') ice: [InternalCombustionEngine] Also, Figure B.18 should show PowerSubsystem with part: ecu:PowerControlUnit Visit also analysis at: http://school.nomagicasia.com/node/149