Issue 12536: Inconsistencies in GQAM (marte-ftf) Source: (, ) Nature: Revision Severity: Significant Summary: A number of inconsistencies have been detected in the GQAM subprofile description. The GaScenario stereotype description changes from the domain description section to the UML stereotype description sections (15.2.2.1, 15.3.1 and 15.3.2.12). Resolution: The differences are mostly in style of expression rather than substance, particularly in a property being expressed as an attribute in a diagram, because it is geometrically awkward to show an association. Attributes and associations are equivalent properties. There are two differences: (b3) timing is correctly represented in Fig 15.3 by an association (b4) timing is missing from the stereotype on p 283, and should be added. (a) GaWorkloadEvent has five properties: in Fig 15.3 in Fig 15.7 in stereotype p 286 • pattern: attrib attrib attrib • generator: assoc attrib attrib • trace: assoc attrib attrib • timeEvent: assoc assoc attrib • effect assoc attrib assoc (proposed in resolution of issue 12538) The textual stereotype is consistent with the meaning of both diagrams, so no change is necessary. (b) The stereotype GaScenario in Figure 15.7 has attributes “cause” and “timing” which are not correctly represented in Fig 15.3 and in the stereotype on p 283. (b1) cause is represented in Fig 15.3 by the association inputStream. This should be changed to cause (b2) cause is not represented in the stereotype at all, it should be added. Revised Text: (b1) Figure 15.3 p 265 Change the association label inputStream on BehaviourScenario to cause. (b2 and b4) old text p 283 sec 15.3.2.12 Attributes • hostDemand: NFP_Duration [*] the cpu demand in units of time, if all Steps are on the same host. (list continues, ending with...) • root: GaStep [0..1] the first Step of the scenario. new text adds an item at the beginning and the end of the list of Attributes Feb 27 09, a description added for the timing attribute, shown in red (Woodside) Attributes • cause: GaWorkloadEvent the event stream which triggers the scenario • hostDemand: NFP_Duration [*] the cpu demand in units of time, if all Steps are on the same host. (list items, ending with • root: GaStep [0..1] the first Step of the scenario. • timing: GaTimingObserver[*] timing observers associated with this scenario. Actions taken: June 19, 2008: received issue October 16, 2009: closed issue Discussion: End of Annotations:===== m: webmaster@omg.org Date: 19 Jun 2008 08:52:42 -0400 To: Subject: Issue/Bug Report -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Name: Adrián Noguero Company: ESI mailFrom: adrian.noguero@esi.es Notification: Yes Specification: Inconsistencies in GQAM Section: 15 FormalNumber: ptc/07-08-04 Version: Beta 1 RevisionDate: 08/04/2007 Page: 658 Nature: Revision Severity: Significant HTTP User Agent: Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SV1; ESI Internet Explorer; .NET CLR 1.1.4322; InfoPath.1) Description A number of inconsistencies have been detected in the GQAM subprofile description. The GaScenario stereotype description changes from the domain description section to the UML stereotype description sections (15.2.2.1, 15.3.1 and 15.3.2.12). Date: Fri, 27 Feb 2009 11:49:26 -0500 (EST) From: Murray Woodside Reply-To: cmw@sce.carleton.ca To: GERARD Sebastien 166342 cc: cmw@sce.carleton.ca, Pete Rivett , marte-ftf@omg.org Subject: Attribute description in resolution of 12536 on ballot 1 User-Agent: Alpine 2.00 (LFD 1167 2008-08-23) Sebastien, Pete, it is true that I left out the description of the timing attribute... it is straightforward, here is a revised resolution. Murray Woodside Distinguished Research Professor Dept of Systems and Computer Engineering, Carleton University, 1125 Colonel By Drive, Ottawa K1S 5B6, Canada. (613)-520-5721.....fax (613)-520-5727....cmw@sce.carleton.ca (http://www.sce.carleton.ca/faculty/woodside.html) On Fri, 27 Feb 2009, GERARD Sebastien 166342 wrote: Hi Murray,  According to the comment of Pete, it seems you miss a description of the timing attributes. Can you provide us the description?  Thanks, Cheers. Sébastien. >  _____________________________________________________________________________________________________ De : Pete Rivett [mailto:pete.rivett@adaptive.com] Envoyé : vendredi 27 février 2009 11:19 Ã. : GERARD Sebastien 166342; marte-ftf@omg.org Objet : RE: MARTE FTF2: ballot 1, start of voting period  Adaptive votes YES on all issues except 1253 6 to which it ABSTAINS (since the timing attribute added at the end of the list seems to be missing a description) and 11820 to which it also ABSTAINS (The UML RTF is also considering changes with respect to required/provided interfaces of Ports).  Pete  From: GERARD Sebastien 166342 [mailto:Sebastien.GERARD@cea.fr] Sent: 19 February 2009 10:01 To: marte-ftf@omg.org Subject: MARTE FTF2: ballot 1, start of voting period  Hi all,  It is now time to start the voting period for the ballot 1 of the MARTE FTF2. Ballot 1 is available here: http://www.omgwiki.org/marte-ftf2/doku.php?id=marte_ftf2_ballot_1 Attached to this email is an excel file I ask you to fill in with your vote. I want to remain you that if you miss too consecutive votes you will be withdraw from the FTF2.  Cheers. Sébastien. >     Dr. Sébastien Gérard Head of MDD for DRES research project CEA LIST/LISE Boîte courrier 65, GIF SUR YVETTE CEDEX, F-91191 France Phone/fax : +33 1 69 08 58 24 / 83 95 Leader of the Eclipse Component Papyrus (The UML2 Graphical Modeler): www.papyrusuml.org http://www.eclipse.org/modeling/mdt/?project=papyrus  Before printing, think about the environment  Date: Fri, 27 Feb 2009 11:49:26 -0500 (EST) From: Murray Woodside Reply-To: cmw@sce.carleton.ca To: GERARD Sebastien 166342 cc: cmw@sce.carleton.ca, Pete Rivett , marte-ftf@omg.org Subject: Attribute description in resolution of 12536 on ballot 1 User-Agent: Alpine 2.00 (LFD 1167 2008-08-23) Sebastien, Pete, it is true that I left out the description of the timing attribute... it is straightforward, here is a revised resolution. Murray Woodside Distinguished Research Professor Dept of Systems and Computer Engineering, Carleton University, 1125 Colonel By Drive, Ottawa K1S 5B6, Canada. (613)-520-5721.....fax (613)-520-5727....cmw@sce.carleton.ca (http://www.sce.carleton.ca/faculty/woodside.html) On Fri, 27 Feb 2009, GERARD Sebastien 166342 wrote: Hi Murray,  According to the comment of Pete, it seems you miss a description of the timing attributes. Can you provide us the description?  Thanks, Cheers. Sébastien. >  _____________________________________________________________________________________________________ De : Pete Rivett [mailto:pete.rivett@adaptive.com] Envoyé : vendredi 27 février 2009 11:19 Ã. : GERARD Sebastien 166342; marte-ftf@omg.org Objet : RE: MARTE FTF2: ballot 1, start of voting period  Adaptive votes YES on all issues except 1253 6 to which it ABSTAINS (since the timing attribute added at the end of the list seems to be missing a description) and 11820 to which it also ABSTAINS (The UML RTF is also considering changes with respect to required/provided interfaces of Ports).  Pete  From: GERARD Sebastien 166342 [mailto:Sebastien.GERARD@cea.fr] Sent: 19 February 2009 10:01 To: marte-ftf@omg.org Subject: MARTE FTF2: ballot 1, start of voting period  Hi all,  It is now time to start the voting period for the ballot 1 of the MARTE FTF2. Ballot 1 is available here: http://www.omgwiki.org/marte-ftf2/doku.php?id=marte_ftf2_ballot_1 Attached to this email is an excel file I ask you to fill in with your vote. I want to remain you that if you miss too consecutive votes you will be withdraw from the FTF2.  Cheers. Sébastien. >     Dr. Sébastien Gérard Head of MDD for DRES research project CEA LIST/LISE Boîte courrier 65, GIF SUR YVETTE CEDEX, F-91191 France Phone/fax : +33 1 69 08 58 24 / 83 95 Leader of the Eclipse Component Papyrus (The UML2 Graphical Modeler): www.papyrusuml.org http://www.eclipse.org/modeling/mdt/?project=papyrus  Before printing, think about the environment  12536_resolved_2.doc Subject: RE: Attribute description in resolution of 12536 on ballot 1 Date: Fri, 27 Feb 2009 17:00:49 -0800 X-MS-Has-Attach: X-MS-TNEF-Correlator: Thread-Topic: Attribute description in resolution of 12536 on ballot 1 Thread-Index: AcmY+2+3qztbFujWRcKWKuDnYlw/MwARFXKA From: "Pete Rivett" To: , "GERARD Sebastien 166342" Cc: X-MIME-Autoconverted: from base64 to 8bit by amethyst.omg.org id n1S10lEc009448 Assuming this change has been officially added to the Ballot as an editorial action by the Chair, then Adaptive changes its ABSTAIN vote on I12536 ssue to YES. Pete -----Original Message----- From: Murray Woodside [mailto:cmw@sce.carleton.ca] Sent: 27 February 2009 08:49 To: GERARD Sebastien 166342 Cc: cmw@sce.carleton.ca; Pete Rivett; marte-ftf@omg.org Subject: Attribute description in resolution of 12536 on ballot 1 Sebastien, Pete, it is true that I left out the description of the timing attribute... it is straightforward, here is a revised resolution. Murray Woodside Distinguished Research Professor Dept of Systems and Computer Engineering, Carleton University, 1125 Colonel By Drive, Ottawa K1S 5B6, Canada. (613)-520-5721.....fax (613)-520-5727....cmw@sce.carleton.ca (http://www.sce.carleton.ca/faculty/woodside.html) On Fri, 27 Feb 2009, GERARD Sebastien 166342 wrote: > > Hi Murray, > >  > > According to the comment of Pete, it seems you miss a description of > the timing attributes. Can you provide us the description? > >  > > Thanks, > > Cheers. Sébastien. > >  > > > ______________________________________________________________________ > _______________________________ > > > De : Pete Rivett [mailto:pete.rivett@adaptive.com] Envoyé : vendredi > 27 février 2009 11:19 Ã. : GERARD Sebastien 166342; marte-ftf@omg.org > Objet : RE: MARTE FTF2: ballot 1, start of voting period > >  > > Adaptive votes YES on all issues except 1253 6 to which it ABSTAINS > (since the timing attribute added at the end of the list seems to be > missing a description) and 11820 to which it also ABSTAINS (The UML RTF is also considering changes with respect to required/provided interfaces of Ports). > >  > > Pete > >  > > From: GERARD Sebastien 166342 [mailto:Sebastien.GERARD@cea.fr] > Sent: 19 February 2009 10:01 > To: marte-ftf@omg.org > Subject: MARTE FTF2: ballot 1, start of voting period > >  > > Hi all, > >  > > It is now time to start the voting period for the ballot 1 of the > MARTE FTF2. Ballot 1 is available > here: > http://www.omgwiki.org/marte-ftf2/doku.php?id=marte_ftf2_ballot_1 > > Attached to this email is an excel file I ask you to fill in with your vote. > > I want to remain you that if you miss too consecutive votes you will be withdraw from the FTF2. > >  > > Cheers. Sébastien. > >  > >  > >  > >  > > Dr. Sébastien Gérard > > Head of MDD for DRES research project > > CEA LIST/LISE > > Boîte courrier 65, GIF SUR YVETTE > > CEDEX, F-91191 France > > Phone/fax : +33 1 69 08 58 24 / 83 95 > > Leader of the Eclipse Component Papyrus (The UML2 Graphical Modeler): > www.papyrusuml.org > > http://www.eclipse.org/modeling/mdt/?project=papyrus > >  > > Before printing, think about the environment > >  > >