Issue 12542: terminological dictionary (sbvr-rtf) Source: International Business Machines (Mr. Mark H. Linehan, mlinehan(at)us.ibm.com) Nature: Uncategorized Issue Severity: Summary: SBVR currently has multiple concepts for organizing vocabularies and rules: * conceptual schema (clause 8.5) * fact model (8.5) * body of shared meanings (11.1.1) * body of shared concepts (11.1.1) * terminological dictionary (11.1.1) * vocabulary (11.1.1) * rulebook (11.2.2.4) Some issues: 3) A terminological dictionary should be able to incorporate other terminological dictionaries, as with "vocabulary incorporates vocabulary". Otherwise, we cannot structure terminological dictionaries in parallel with vocabularies Resolution: Revised Text: Actions taken: June 20, 2008: received issue Discussion: End of Annotations:===== s is issue # 12542 terminological dictionary SBVR currently has multiple concepts for organizing vocabularies and rules: * conceptual schema (clause 8.5) * fact model (8.5) * body of shared meanings (11.1.1) * body of shared concepts (11.1.1) * terminological dictionary (11.1.1) * vocabulary (11.1.1) * rulebook (11.2.2.4) Some issues: 3) A terminological dictionary should be able to incorporate other terminological dictionaries, as with "vocabulary incorporates vocabulary". Otherwise, we cannot structure terminological dictionaries in parallel with DomainKey-Signature: a=rsa-sha1; q=dns; c=nofws; s=s1024; d=btinternet.com; h=Received:X-YMail-OSG:X-Yahoo-Newman-Property:Reply-To:From:To:Subject:Date:Organization:Message-ID:MIME-Version:Content-Type:X-Mailer:X-MimeOLE:Thread-Index; b=QQSw2zsZcTIxQkSSQHha9D2a0dLVHmDdtHyykg5yvskjjIpEljgT+5Mp0LvG4oTL2qXELBfiWfDiECVlQVtymkuuYDdz2Xq1+nq9ZUeQklS+n3hrNMb34djXxKj+DnyG8Ujhc6y3T1IXvL4AeD1d3zfHkSG75SAjm33u5RsZLJk= ; X-YMail-OSG: 7Fit9FcVM1mbMuluoXbkB3HOn79nwUqigsUnN.1hnNIxltsvoQXjkP9whrXlhdqZBwtb.oa.cYTDSGe9Y_L.y_uvWEZGPoDgyRJgnJvl7r0nf4dSwJsuTioflhRoufWjZMznz_n1Z7lJWjA7RXhBkm4xqDSpg.0jF97Qy7osEmmmVrN4mI49FL_9Rxo- X-Yahoo-Newman-Property: ymail-3 Reply-To: From: "Donald Chapin" To: Subject: FW: issues 12542 -- SBVR RTF issues - Proposed Resolution Date: Wed, 10 Dec 2008 15:40:33 -0800 Organization: Business Semantics Ltd X-Mailer: Microsoft Office Outlook 11 Thread-Index: Ack+jEfvg90sYkFQRDWHE5wuyUGLJgck8MsA -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- From: Mark H Linehan [mailto:mlinehan@us.ibm.com] Sent: Tuesday, November 04, 2008 6:48 AM To: Donald.Chapin@btinternet.com Subject: Re: FW: issues 12542 -- SBVR RTF issues Donald, I'm ok with the approach you propose. But I don't particularly care for the database analogy since that analogy is not used anywhere else in the spec. I tightened-up the writeup: (See attached file: Proposed Issue 12542 Resolution.doc) -------------------------------- Mark H. Linehan STSM, Model Driven Business Transformation IBM Research phone: (914) 945-1038 or IBM tieline 862-1038 internet: mlinehan@us.ibm.com "Donald Chapin" "Donald Chapin" 10/29/2008 12:29 PM Please respond to To Mark H Linehan/Watson/IBM@IBMUS cc Subject FW: issues 12542 -- SBVR RTF issues Mark, I have attached a proposed write-up for the resolution to Issue 12542. Could you review it and see if it is clear, and if shows how the function you are looking for is already in SBVR. If I've not been clear or if I have not understood the problem you had in mind, please let me know and I'll fix the proposed resolution. If it would help, I'd to happy to call you to discuss this. Best Regards, Donald > This is issue # 12542 > > terminological dictionary > > SBVR currently has multiple concepts for organizing vocabularies and > rules: > > > * conceptual schema (clause 8.5) > * fact model (8.5) > * body of shared meanings (11.1.1) > * body of shared concepts (11.1.1) > * terminological dictionary (11.1.1) > * vocabulary (11.1.1) > * rulebook (11.2.2.4) > > > Some issues: > 3) A terminological dictionary should be able to incorporate other > terminological dictionaries, as with "vocabulary incorporates vocabulary". > Otherwise, we cannot structure terminological dictionaries in parallel > with > vocabularies > (See attached file: Issue 12542 Resolution.doc) DomainKey-Signature: a=rsa-sha1; q=dns; c=nofws; s=s1024; d=btinternet.com; h=Received:X-Yahoo-Newman-Property:Reply-To:From:To:References:Subject:Date:Organization:Message-ID:MIME-Version:Content-Type:X-Mailer:X-MimeOLE:In-Reply-To:Thread-Index; b=PyThINTxZyvyu59NHwLiWy2Yfz4tO25nIP9xcqshBC4wXH/Hl6WO2xkoulUtl3tPi6bSmSGy/eWbEq9ZMFbhrtIuiDPJ+wLrGyGOC7tlZrFZ+shLXHCdHekyLnFIMb7L6vHXJh4Mvpij4l7Th8mToPhvfyl9Lb0udwxMx2uaGFM= ; X-Yahoo-Newman-Property: ymail-3 Reply-To: From: "Donald Chapin" To: Subject: RE: issues 12542-- SBVR RTF issues Date: Thu, 29 Jan 2009 10:04:49 -0000 Organization: Business Semantics Ltd X-Mailer: Microsoft Office Outlook 11 Thread-Index: AcjTEgI10U/bPuZYS1C396gUBwLaYCu5l+hw The revised Issue 12542 Resolution from the December SBVR RTF face to face meeting is attached. Donald > -----Original Message----- > From: Juergen Boldt [mailto:juergen@omg.org] > Sent: Friday, June 20, 2008 9:12 PM > To: issues@omg.org; sbvr-rtf@omg.org > Subject: issues 12542 - 12543 -- SBVR RTF issues > > This is issue # 12542 > > terminological dictionary > > SBVR currently has multiple concepts for organizing vocabularies and > rules: > > > * conceptual schema (clause 8.5) > * fact model (8.5) > * body of shared meanings (11.1.1) > * body of shared concepts (11.1.1) > * terminological dictionary (11.1.1) > * vocabulary (11.1.1) > * rulebook (11.2.2.4) > > > Some issues: > 3) A terminological dictionary should be able to incorporate other > terminological dictionaries, as with "vocabulary incorporates vocabulary". > Otherwise, we cannot structure terminological dictionaries in parallel > with > vocabularies > > ============================================================= > > This is issue # 12543 > > A rulebook should have a URI > > SBVR currently has multiple concepts for organizing vocabularies and > rules: > > > * conceptual schema (clause 8.5) > * fact model (8.5) > * body of shared meanings (11.1.1) > * body of shared concepts (11.1.1) > * terminological dictionary (11.1.1) > * vocabulary (11.1.1) > * rulebook (11.2.2.4) > > > Some issues: > 4) A rulebook should have a URI, so that the rulebook can be addressed > over > the Internet. > > > > Juergen Boldt > Director, Member Services > Object Management Group > 140 Kendrick St > Building A Suite 300 > Needham, MA 02494 > USA > > tel: +1 781 444 0404 x 132 > fax: +1 781 444 0320 > email: juergen@omg.org > www.omg.org vocabularies