Issue 15878: References in KDM for UML, MOF, and XMI are not current (kdm-rtf) Source: Fujitsu (Mr. Tom Rutt, tom(at)coastin.com) Nature: Uncategorized Issue Severity: Summary: The references to UML, MOF and XMI in the KDM 2.2 are not appropriate. The references to 19502:2005 and 10503:2005 are not used anywhere in the spec and should be removed. The ref to MOF should be to the actual version used. The proposed resolution below assumes the Latest Versions used are MOF 2.0 and XMI 2.1.1. Proposed solution: In section 3 Change: “ 3 Normative References The following normative documents contain provisions, which, through reference in this text, constitute provisions of this specification. For dated references, subsequent amendments to or revisions of any of these publications do not apply. • OMG UML 2.2 Infrastructure Specification formal/2009-02-04 • OMG Meta-Object Facility (MOF) ver. 2.0 formal/2006-01-01 • OMG Semantics of Business Vocabularies and Business Rules (SBVR) Ver 1.0 formal/08-01-02 • ISO/IEC 19502:2005 Information technology -- Meta Object Facility (MOF) • ISO/IEC 19503:2005 Information technology -- XML Metadata Interchange (XMI) • ISO/IEC 11404:2007 Information technology -- General-Purpose Datatypes (GPD) “ To: “ 3 Normative References The following normative documents contain provisions, which, through reference in this text, constitute provisions of this specification. For dated references, subsequent amendments to or revisions of any of these publications do not apply. • OMG UML 2.4 Infrastructure Specification <omg spec ref URL> • OMG Meta-Object Facility (MOF) ver. 2.0 <OMG spec ref URL> • OMG MOF XML Metadata Interchange (XMI) ver. 2.1.1 <OMG spec ref URL> • OMG Semantics of Business Vocabularies and Business Rules (SBVR) Ver 1.0 formal/08-01-02 • ISO/IEC 11404:2007 Information technology -- General-Purpose Datatypes (GPD) " Resolution: Revised Text: Actions taken: December 7, 2010: received issue Discussion: End of Annotations:===== uthentication-Results: cm-omr3 smtp.user=tom@coastenterprises.com; auth=pass (PLAIN) X-Authenticated-UID: tom@coastenterprises.com Date: Tue, 07 Dec 2010 18:08:08 -0500 From: Tom Rutt Reply-To: tom@coastin.com User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1; en-US; rv:1.9.2.12) Gecko/20101027 Thunderbird/3.1.6 To: kdm-rtf@omg.org, "ab@omg.org" , issues@omg.org, Juergen Boldt , Tom Rutt , Nikolai Mansourov Subject: New ADM/KDM RTF issue Juergen, please file this issue, and assign it to KDM RTF. If possible, the KDM RTF could resolve it before the RTF closes. New ISSUE yyyyyy ADM/KDM 2.2 Source: Tom Rutt, Fujitsu Title: References in KDM for UML, MOF, and XMI are not current. Nature of Problem: The references to UML, MOF and XMI in the KDM 2.2 are not appropriate. The references to 19502:2005 and 10503:2005 are not used anywhere in the spec and should be removed. The ref to MOF should be to the actual version used. The proposed resolution below assumes the Latest Versions used are MOF 2.0 and XMI 2.1.1. Proposed solution: In section 3 Change: . 3 Normative References The following normative documents contain provisions, which, through reference in this text, constitute provisions of this specification. For dated references, subsequent amendments to or revisions of any of these publications do not apply. . OMG UML 2.2 Infrastructure Specification formal/2009-02-04 . OMG Meta-Object Facility (MOF) ver. 2.0 formal/2006-01-01 . OMG Semantics of Business Vocabularies and Business Rules (SBVR) Ver 1.0 formal/08-01-02 . ISO/IEC 19502:2005 Information technology -- Meta Object Facility (MOF) . ISO/IEC 19503:2005 Information technology -- XML Metadata Interchange (XMI) . ISO/IEC 11404:2007 Information technology -- General-Purpose Datatypes (GPD) . To: . 3 Normative References The following normative documents contain provisions, which, through reference in this text, constitute provisions of this specification. For dated references, subsequent amendments to or revisions of any of these publications do not apply. . OMG UML 2.4 Infrastructure Specification . OMG Meta-Object Facility (MOF) ver. 2.0 . OMG MOF XML Metadata Interchange (XMI) ver. 2.1.1 . OMG Semantics of Business Vocabularies and Business Rules (SBVR) Ver 1.0 formal/08-01-02 . ISO/IEC 11404:2007 Information technology -- General-Purpose Datatypes (GPD) " -- ---------------------------------------------------- Tom Rutt email: tom@coastin.com; trutt@us.fujitsu.com Tel: +1 732 801 5744 Fax: +1 732 774 5133 Date: Wed, 08 Dec 2010 19:37:17 -0500 From: Tom Rutt Reply-To: tom@coastin.com User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1; en-US; rv:1.9.2.12) Gecko/20101027 Thunderbird/3.1.6 To: tom@coastin.com CC: kdm-rtf@omg.org, ab@omg.org, Nikolai Mansourov Subject: Re: New ADM/KDM RTF issue On 12/8/2010 12:30 PM, Tom Rutt wrote: On 12/7/2010 6:08 PM, Tom Rutt wrote: Juergen, please file this issue, and assign it to KDM RTF. If possible, the KDM RTF could resolve it before the RTF closes. I just realized this is closely related to the Issue 13826 - references from Japan. Thus I think we should resolve these two issues together. Tom New ISSUE yyyyyy ADM/KDM 2.2 Source: Tom Rutt, Fujitsu Title: References in KDM for UML, MOF, and XMI are not current. A correction needs to be made to the proposed resolution. I think the resolution needs to be that the References in the output of this RTF be to the versions of the reference specs which were available at the time the RTF was doing its work. The proposed resolution needs to be amended so that the UML reference be changed to UML 2.3, and the MOF ref should be to MOF 2.0, and the XMI ref to XMI 2.1.1. Tom Rutt Nature of Problem: The references to UML, MOF and XMI in the KDM 2.2 are not appropriate. The references to 19502:2005 and 10503:2005 are not used anywhere in the spec and should be removed. The ref to MOF should be to the actual version used. The proposed resolution below assumes the Latest Versions used are MOF 2.0 and XMI 2.1.1. Proposed solution: In section 3 Change: rmative References The following normative documents contain provisions, which, through reference in this text, constitute provisions of this specification. For dated references, subsequent amendments to or revisions of any of these publications do not apply. . OMG UML 2.2 Infrastructure Specification formal/2009-02-04 . OMG Meta-Object Facility (MOF) ver. 2.0 formal/2006-01-01 . OMG Semantics of Business Vocabularies and Business Rules (SBVR) Ver 1.0 formal/08-01-02 . ISO/IEC 19502:2005 Information technology -- Meta Object Facility (MOF) . ISO/IEC 19503:2005 Information technology -- XML Metadata Interchange (XMI) . ISO/IEC 11404:2007 Information technology -- General-Purpose Datatypes (GPD) . To: . 3 Normative References The following normative documents contain provisions, which, through reference in this text, constitute provisions of this specification. For dated references, subsequent amendments to or revisions of any of these publications do not apply. . OMG UML 2.4 Infrastructure Specification . OMG Meta-Object Facility (MOF) ver. 2.0 . OMG MOF XML Metadata Interchange (XMI) ver. 2.1.1 . OMG Semantics of Business Vocabularies and Business Rules (SBVR) Ver 1.0 formal/08-01-02 . ISO/IEC 11404:2007 Information technology -- General-Purpose Datatypes (GPD) " -- ---------------------------------------------------- Tom Rutt email: tom@coastin.com; trutt@us.fujitsu.com Tel: +1 732 801 5744 Fax: +1 732 774 5133 Authentication-Results: cm-omr6 smtp.user=tom@coastenterprises.com; auth=pass (PLAIN) X-Authenticated-UID: tom@coastenterprises.com Date: Wed, 08 Dec 2010 12:30:36 -0500 From: Tom Rutt Reply-To: tom@coastin.com User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1; en-US; rv:1.9.2.12) Gecko/20101027 Thunderbird/3.1.6 To: tom@coastin.com CC: kdm-rtf@omg.org, "ab@omg.org" , Nikolai Mansourov Subject: Re: New ADM/KDM RTF issue On 12/7/2010 6:08 PM, Tom Rutt wrote: Juergen, please file this issue, and assign it to KDM RTF. If possible, the KDM RTF could resolve it before the RTF closes. New ISSUE yyyyyy ADM/KDM 2.2 Source: Tom Rutt, Fujitsu Title: References in KDM for UML, MOF, and XMI are not current. A correction needs to be made to the proposed resolution. I think the resolution needs to be that the References in the output of this RTF be to the versions of the reference specs which were available at the time the RTF was doing its work. The proposed resolution needs to be amended so that the UML reference be changed to UML 2.3, and the MOF ref should be to MOF 2.0, and the XMI ref to XMI 2.1.1. Tom Rutt Nature of Problem: The references to UML, MOF and XMI in the KDM 2.2 are not appropriate. The references to 19502:2005 and 10503:2005 are not used anywhere in the spec and should be removed. The ref to MOF should be to the actual version used. The proposed resolution below assumes the Latest Versions used are MOF 2.0 and XMI 2.1.1. Proposed solution: In section 3 Change: rmative References The following normative documents contain provisions, which, through reference in this text, constitute provisions of this specification. For dated references, subsequent amendments to or revisions of any of these publications do not apply. . OMG UML 2.2 Infrastructure Specification formal/2009-02-04 . OMG Meta-Object Facility (MOF) ver. 2.0 formal/2006-01-01 . OMG Semantics of Business Vocabularies and Business Rules (SBVR) Ver 1.0 formal/08-01-02 . ISO/IEC 19502:2005 Information technology -- Meta Object Facility (MOF) . ISO/IEC 19503:2005 Information technology -- XML Metadata Interchange (XMI) . ISO/IEC 11404:2007 Information technology -- General-Purpose Datatypes (GPD) . To: . 3 Normative References The following normative documents contain provisions, which, through reference in this text, constitute provisions of this specification. For dated references, subsequent amendments to or revisions of any of these publications do not apply. . OMG UML 2.4 Infrastructure Specification . OMG Meta-Object Facility (MOF) ver. 2.0 . OMG MOF XML Metadata Interchange (XMI) ver. 2.1.1 . OMG Semantics of Business Vocabularies and Business Rules (SBVR) Ver 1.0 formal/08-01-02 . ISO/IEC 11404:2007 Information technology -- General-Purpose Datatypes (GPD) " -- ---------------------------------------------------- Tom Rutt email: tom@coastin.com; trutt@us.fujitsu.com Tel: +1 732 801 5744 Fax: +1 732 774 5133