Issue 15948: is-property-of fact types (sbvr-rtf) Source: Ajilon (Mr. Graham Witt, ) Nature: Revision Severity: Significant Summary: The example fact type in section 11.1.5.1 under “is-property-of fact type” is “engine size is property of car model” yet the examples in Annex E do not have this form. Further if one tries to instantiate this fact type, one gets something like “351 cubic inches is property of Holden Marina” which misses essential information. I believe that ‘is-property-of’ fact types should each have the 2 forms “engine size of car model is cubic measurement”/“car model has engine size of cubic measurement” allowing for instantiations such as “engine size of Holden Marina is 351 cubic inches”/“Holden Marina has engine size of 351 cubic inches”. Resolution: Revised Text: Actions taken: January 14, 2011: received issue Discussion: End of Annotations:===== m: webmaster@omg.org Date: 14 Jan 2011 00:20:34 -0500 To: Subject: Issue/Bug Report ******************************************************************************* Name: Graham Witt Employer: Ajilon mailFrom: graham.witt@ajilon.com.au Terms_Agreement: I agree Specification: SBVR Section: various FormalNumber: formal/2008-01-02 Version: 1.0 Doc_Year: 2008 Doc_Month: January Doc_Day: 02 Page: various Title: is-property-of fact types Nature: Revision Severity: Significant CODE: 3TMw8 B1: Report Issue Description: The example fact type in section 11.1.5.1 under .is-property-of fact type. is .engine size is property of car model. yet the examples in Annex E do not have this form. Further if one tries to instantiate this fact type, one gets something like .351 cubic inches is property of Holden Marina. which misses essential information. I believe that .is-property-of. fact types should each have the 2 forms .engine size of car model is cubic measurement./.car model has engine size of cubic measurement. allowing for instantiations such as .engine size of Holden Marina is 351 cubic inches./.Holden Marina has engine size of 351 cubic inches.. X-Proofpoint-Virus-Version: vendor=fsecure engine=2.50.10432:5.2.15,1.0.148,0.0.0000 definitions=2011-02-24_08:2011-02-24,2011-02-24,1970-01-01 signatures=0 X-Proofpoint-Spam-Details: rule=notspam policy=default score=0 spamscore=0 ipscore=0 suspectscore=0 phishscore=0 bulkscore=0 adultscore=0 classifier=spam adjust=0 reason=mlx engine=6.0.2-1012030000 definitions=main-1102240075 From: keri Subject: Re: issue 15948 -- SBVR RTF issue Date: Thu, 24 Feb 2011 09:03:23 -1000 To: sbvr-rtf@omg.org, Donald Chapin X-Mailer: Apple Mail (2.1082) Resolution write-up attached. ~ Keri On Jan 14, 2011, at 5:46 AM, Juergen Boldt wrote: > >> From: webmaster@omg.org >> Date: 14 Jan 2011 00:20:34 -0500 >> To: >> Subject: Issue/Bug Report >> >> ******************************************************************************* >> Name: Graham Witt >> Employer: Ajilon >> mailFrom: graham.witt@ajilon.com.au >> Terms_Agreement: I agree >> Specification: SBVR >> Section: various >> FormalNumber: formal/2008-01-02 >> Version: 1.0 >> Doc_Year: 2008 >> Doc_Month: January >> Doc_Day: 02 >> Page: various >> Title: is-property-of fact types >> Nature: Revision >> Severity: Significant >> CODE: 3TMw8 >> B1: Report Issue >> >> Description: >> >> The example fact type in section 11.1.5.1 under .is-property-of fact type. is .engine size is property of car model. yet the examples in Annex E do not have this form. Further if one tries to instantiate this fact type, one gets something like .351 cubic inches is property of Holden Marina. which misses essential information. I believe that .is-property-of. fact types should each have the 2 forms .engine size of car model is cubic measurement./.car model has engine size of cubic measurement. allowing for instantiations such as .engine size of Holden Marina is 351 cubic inches./.Holden Marina has engine size of 351 cubic inches.. Resolution write-up attached. ~ Keri Issue 15948.doc On Jan 14, 2011, at 5:46 AM, Juergen Boldt wrote: From: webmaster@omg.org Date: 14 Jan 2011 00:20:34 -0500 To: Subject: Issue/Bug Report ******************************************************************************* Name: Graham Witt Employer: Ajilon mailFrom: graham.witt@ajilon.com.au Terms_Agreement: I agree Specification: SBVR Section: various FormalNumber: formal/2008-01-02 Version: 1.0 Doc_Year: 2008 Doc_Month: January Doc_Day: 02 Page: various Title: is-property-of fact types Nature: Revision Severity: Significant CODE: 3TMw8 B1: Report Issue Description: The example fact type in section 11.1.5.1 under .is-property-of fact type. is .engine size is property of car model. yet the examples in Annex E do not have this form. Further if one tries to instantiate this fact type, one gets something like .351 cubic inches is property of Holden Marina. which misses essential information. I believe that .is-property-of. fact types should each have the 2 forms .engine size of car model is cubic measurement./.car model has engine size of cubic measurement. allowing for instantiations such as .engine size of Holden Marina is 351 cubic inches./.Holden Marina has engine size of 351 cubic inches.. Disposition: No Change OMG Issue No: 15948 Title: is-property-of fact types Source: Submitted by: Graham Witt Write-up by: Keri Anderson Healy, Business Rule Solutions LLC (keri_ah@mac.com) Summary: The example fact type in section 11.1.5.1 under "is-property-of fact type" is "engine size is property of car model" yet the examples in Annex E do not have this form. Further if one tries to instantiate this fact type, one gets something like "351 cubic inches is property of Holden Marina" which misses essential information. I believe that 'is-property-of' fact types should each have the 2 forms "engine size of car model is cubic measurement"/"car model has engine size of cubic measurement" allowing for instantiations such as "engine size of Holden Marina is 351 cubic inches"/"Holden Marina has engine size of 351 cubic inches". Resolution: "Is-property-of fact type" was revised in the Resolution of Issue 13716. Specifically, the concept 'property association' (formerly 'is-property-of fact type') now gives these as examples: Example: the association 'engine size of car model' Example: the association 'person has eye color' The concept 'engine size' handles, as needed, appropriate units-of-measure as part of its definition. For example, here is a typical definition of 'engine size': Engine size: volume swept by all the pistons inside the cylinders of an internal combustion engine in a single movement from top dead centre (TDC) to bottom dead centre (BDC) [Engine size is commonly specified in cubic centimeters (cc), litres (l), or cubic inches (cid).] Example instances of engine size could be: 61 cid (cubic inches), 151 cid, 351 cid, etc. And an example fact could be "The car model 'Buick' has the engine size '151 cid'." Alternatively, this could be expressed as "The car model 'Buick' has an engine size '2.5 liter'." since '151 cid' and '2.5 liter' are alternative expressions of the same engine size value. The examples in Annex E are being revised to reflect changes made under Issue 13716 (et al). Revised Text: None needed. Disposition: No Change X-Proofpoint-Virus-Version: vendor=fsecure engine=2.50.10432:5.2.15,1.0.148,0.0.0000 definitions=2011-03-03_06:2011-03-03,2011-03-03,1970-01-01 signatures=0 X-Proofpoint-Spam-Details: rule=notspam policy=default score=0 spamscore=0 ipscore=0 suspectscore=0 phishscore=0 bulkscore=0 adultscore=0 classifier=spam adjust=0 reason=mlx engine=6.0.2-1012030000 definitions=main-1103030116 From: keri Subject: Re: issue 15948 -- SBVR RTF issue Date: Thu, 03 Mar 2011 08:54:47 -1000 To: sbvr-rtf@omg.org, Donald Chapin X-Mailer: Apple Mail (2.1082) Revised Resolution write-up attached, updating (only) the wording of the Resolution to "Merged with 13716" per today's discussion. ~ Keri On Feb 24, 2011, at 9:03 AM, keri wrote: > Resolution write-up attached. ~ Keri > > > > On Jan 14, 2011, at 5:46 AM, Juergen Boldt wrote: >> >>> From: webmaster@omg.org >>> Date: 14 Jan 2011 00:20:34 -0500 >>> To: >>> Subject: Issue/Bug Report >>> >>> ******************************************************************************* >>> Name: Graham Witt >>> Employer: Ajilon >>> mailFrom: graham.witt@ajilon.com.au >>> Terms_Agreement: I agree >>> Specification: SBVR >>> Section: various >>> FormalNumber: formal/2008-01-02 >>> Version: 1.0 >>> Doc_Year: 2008 >>> Doc_Month: January >>> Doc_Day: 02 >>> Page: various >>> Title: is-property-of fact types >>> Nature: Revision >>> Severity: Significant >>> CODE: 3TMw8 >>> B1: Report Issue >>> >>> Description: >>> >>> The example fact type in section 11.1.5.1 under .is-property-of fact type. is .engine size is property of car model. yet the examples in Annex E do not have this form. Further if one tries to instantiate this fact type, one gets something like .351 cubic inches is property of Holden Marina. which misses essential information. I believe that .is-property-of. fact types should each have the 2 forms .engine size of car model is cubic measurement./.car model has engine size of cubic measurement. allowing for instantiations such as .engine size of Holden Marina is 351 cubic inches./.Holden Marina has engine size of 351 cubic inches.. > Revised Resolution write-up attached, updating (only) the wording of the Resolution to "Merged with 13716" per today's discussion. ~ Keri Issue 15948-RESOLUTION(v2).doc On Feb 24, 2011, at 9:03 AM, keri wrote: Resolution write-up attached. ~ Keri On Jan 14, 2011, at 5:46 AM, Juergen Boldt wrote: From: webmaster@omg.org Date: 14 Jan 2011 00:20:34 -0500 To: Subject: Issue/Bug Report ******************************************************************************* Name: Graham Witt Employer: Ajilon mailFrom: graham.witt@ajilon.com.au Terms_Agreement: I agree Specification: SBVR Section: various FormalNumber: formal/2008-01-02 Version: 1.0 Doc_Year: 2008 Doc_Month: January Doc_Day: 02 Page: various Title: is-property-of fact types Nature: Revision Severity: Significant CODE: 3TMw8 B1: Report Issue Description: The example fact type in section 11.1.5.1 under .is-property-of fact type. is .engine size is property of car model. yet the examples in Annex E do not have this form. Further if one tries to instantiate this fact type, one gets something like .351 cubic inches is property of Holden Marina. which misses essential information. I believe that .is-property-of. fact types should each have the 2 forms .engine size of car model is cubic measurement./.car model has engine size of cubic measurement. allowing for instantiations such as .engine size of Holden Marina is 351 cubic inches./.Holden Marina has engine size of 351 cubic inches.. Disposition: Merged with 13716 OMG Issue No: 15948 Title: is-property-of fact types Source: Submitted by: Graham Witt Write-up by: Keri Anderson Healy, Business Rule Solutions LLC (keri_ah@mac.com) Summary: The example fact type in section 11.1.5.1 under "is-property-of fact type" is "engine size is property of car model" yet the examples in Annex E do not have this form. Further if one tries to instantiate this fact type, one gets something like "351 cubic inches is property of Holden Marina" which misses essential information. I believe that 'is-property-of' fact types should each have the 2 forms "engine size of car model is cubic measurement"/"car model has engine size of cubic measurement" allowing for instantiations such as "engine size of Holden Marina is 351 cubic inches"/"Holden Marina has engine size of 351 cubic inches". Resolution: "Is-property-of fact type" was revised in the Resolution of Issue 13716. Specifically, the concept 'property association' (formerly 'is-property-of fact type') now gives these as examples: Example: the association 'engine size of car model' Example: the association 'person has eye color' The concept 'engine size' handles, as needed, appropriate units-of-measure as part of its definition. For example, here is a typical definition of 'engine size': Engine size: volume swept by all the pistons inside the cylinders of an internal combustion engine in a single movement from top dead centre (TDC) to bottom dead centre (BDC) [Engine size is commonly specified in cubic centimeters (cc), litres (l), or cubic inches (cid).] Example instances of engine size could be: 61 cid (cubic inches), 151 cid, 351 cid, etc. And an example fact could be "The car model 'Buick' has the engine size '151 cid'." Alternatively, this could be expressed as "The car model 'Buick' has an engine size '2.5 liter'." since '151 cid' and '2.5 liter' are alternative expressions of the same engine size value. The examples in Annex E are being revised to reflect changes made under Issue 13716 (et al). Revised Text: None needed. Disposition: Merged with 13716