Issue 16129: Issue nnnn: Japan PAS Ballot Comment 6 (ocl2-rtf) (ocl2-rtf)
Source:  (Mr. Tom Rutt, nobody)
Nature: Uncategorized Issue
Severity: 
Summary: There are same element names in both OCL and UML. Those are confusing. I wonder whether those are UML elements or OCL elements. Besides, it seems there is no clear distinction between UML/OCL (upper case letter) term and general term (lower case letter), since these are used in mixture.
- It is confusing to distinguish OCL “Constraint” from UML “Constraint” in the text. Furthermore, there are some “constraint” s (in a lower case letter). The lower case letter/upper case letters for “constraint” are mixed. 
OCL “Constraint” should be distinguishable from UML “Constrain”.
Resolution: Not much of a title.
There are many element names that are the reused in UML; presumably class names were meant. I think that these are all distinct and not confusing to me. No convincing example is given. The example of a Constraint is where UML and OCL overlap so it is obviously the same class.
Spelling is separately raised as Issue 16126 so there is no need to address it here as well.
Disposition: Closed, no change
Revised Text: 
Actions taken:
April 20, 2011: received issue
December 23, 2013: closed issue
Discussion: 
See comment JP 6 in “…_JISC.doc”  file in http://www.omg.org/members/cgi-bin/doc?pas/11-03-03.zip Initial Comment/Suggestion: : OCL “Constraint” should be distinguishable from UML
“Constraint”.
Comment: In fact OCL do not define the concept of Constraint since this concept is taken from UML. So
there is no need to distinguish them since they are the same concept.
A more detailed check to the spec is needed to see if this issue requires any change.
Disposition: Deferred
End of Annotations:=====
s is issue # 16129


Issue 16129: Japan PAS Ballot Comment 6 (ocl2-rtf)

Click here for this issue's archive. 
Nature: Issue from PAS Ballot comment for ISO/IEC DIS 19507
Severity: 
Summary: 

See comment JP 6 in .._JISC.doc.  file in http://www.omg.org/members/cgi-bin/doc?pas/11-03-03.zip
Resolution: 
Revised Text: 
Actions taken: