Issue 16575: xmi:uuid in Canonical XMI (canonical-xmi-ftf)
Source: NASA (Dr. Nicolas F. Rouquette, nicolas.f.rouquette(at)jpl.nasa.gov)
Nature: Uncategorized Issue
Severity: 
Summary: This attribute is used for ordering elements as described in B.5

Since Canonical XMI makes xmi:uuid mandatory, it seems reasonable to expect that some tools may change the value of xmi:ids on import/export. It seems that Canonical XMI should require a scheme such as option 3 in XMI 2.4, section 7.10.2.2 for linking across XMI documents.

Currently, Canonical XMI does not make such restriction on the scheme for linking across documents.
Since the xmi:id based scheme (option 1 in XMI 2.4, section 7.10.2.2) is the most common, it means that Canonical XMI serialization implicitly requires tools to preserve xmi:id values on import/export.

If the requirement on preserving xmi:id values is too strong, then Canonical XMI needs to require a cross-document linking scheme that is based on xmi:uuid values and that specifically prohibits using xmi:id values except for references within the same document.


Resolution: 
Revised Text: 
Actions taken:
August 28, 2011: received issue
Discussion: 

End of Annotations:=====
s is issue # 16575	nicolas.f.rouquette@jpl.nasa.gov

xmi:uuid in Canonical XMI

This attribute is used for ordering elements as described in B.5

Since Canonical XMI makes xmi:uuid mandatory, it seems reasonable to expect that some tools may change the value of xmi:ids on import/export. It seems that Canonical XMI should require a scheme such as option 3 in XMI 2.4, section 7.10.2.2 for linking across XMI documents.

Currently, Canonical XMI does not make such restriction on the scheme for linking across documents.
Since the xmi:id based scheme (option 1 in XMI 2.4, section 7.10.2.2) is the most common, it means that Canonical XMI serialization implicitly requires tools to preserve xmi:id values on import/export.

If the requirement on preserving xmi:id values is too strong, then Canonical XMI needs to require a cross-document linking scheme that is based on xmi:uuid values and that specifically prohibits using xmi:id values except for references within the same document.