Issue 17095: "Include DoDAF 2.02 Conformance Level Three (L3) Statement" (updm-2-0-rtf)
Source: Office of the Secretary of Defense (Mr. Leonard F. Levine, Leonard.F.Levine.civ(at)mail.mil)
Nature: Uncategorized Issue
Severity: 
Summary: "Section 3.3 Department of Defense" (Normative References) and/or "Section 2 Compliance".


A paragraph needs to be added related to "DoDAF 2.02 Conformance Level Three (DoDAF L3)."


UPDM 2.0 conforms with Level Three (3) as specified by DoDAF 2.02. 
The DoDAF Levels of conformance are:


        DoDAF Level 1 is conceptual conformance.
        DoDAF Level 2 is logical data model conformance.
        DoDAF Level 3 is physical data model conformance.
        DoDAF Level 4 is syntactic/ontology conformance with a full spatial-temporal (4-dimensional) ontology.


        Note: DoDAF Levels are not to be confused with UPDM Levels.


        Note: DoDAF Levels are cumulative, that is, Level 3 physical data model conformance builds upon Level 2, logical data model conformance. 
                One cannot achieve DoDAF Level 3 without achieving DoDAF Levels 1 and 2.


As evidence of conformance at the logical data model level (DoDAF Level 2), we refer the reader internally to Annex C.1, "DoDAF-DM2, UPDM, and MODAF Mapping".  For DoDAF Level 3, we cite the proven exchanges among UPDM 2.0 implementations at the physical layer using the OMG XML Model Interchange (XMI) specification. Tools that conform with UPDM Level 0 or UPDM Level 1 must be able to make this XMI interchange.  See internal section 2.1.1 and 2.1.2


Len Levine for US DoD




Resolution: 
Revised Text: 
Actions taken:
February 2, 2012: received issue
Discussion: 

End of Annotations:=====
ubject: UPDM 2.0 Conformance with DoDAF 2.02 at Level 3 (UNCLASSIFIED)
From: "Levine, Leonard F CIV DISA EE" <Leonard.Levine@disa.mil>
To: <updm-2-0-rtf@omg.org>
Cc: "Okon, Walt, Mr, DoD CIO ...snip...
        "Juergen Boldt" <juergen@omg.org>


Classification:  UNCLASSIFIED 
Caveats: NONE


Issue with UPDM 2.0 for revision in UPDM 2.1.  
Title: "Include DoDAF 2.02 Conformance Level Three (L3) Statement"


"Section 3.3 Department of Defense" (Normative References) and/or "Section 2 Compliance".


A paragraph needs to be added related to "DoDAF 2.02 Conformance Level Three (DoDAF L3)."


UPDM 2.0 conforms with Level Three (3) as specified by DoDAF 2.02. 
The DoDAF Levels of conformance are:


        DoDAF Level 1 is conceptual conformance.
        DoDAF Level 2 is logical data model conformance.
        DoDAF Level 3 is physical data model conformance.
        DoDAF Level 4 is syntactic/ontology conformance with a full spatial-temporal (4-dimensional) ontology.


        Note: DoDAF Levels are not to be confused with UPDM Levels.


        Note: DoDAF Levels are cumulative, that is, Level 3 physical data model conformance builds upon Level 2, logical data model conformance. 
                One cannot achieve DoDAF Level 3 without achieving DoDAF Levels 1 and 2.


As evidence of conformance at the logical data model level (DoDAF Level 2), we refer the reader internally to Annex C.1, "DoDAF-DM2, UPDM, and MODAF Mapping".  For DoDAF Level 3, we cite the proven exchanges among UPDM 2.0 implementations at the physical layer using the OMG XML Model Interchange (XMI) specification. Tools that conform with UPDM Level 0 or UPDM Level 1 must be able to make this XMI interchange.  See internal section 2.1.1 and 2.1.2


Len Levine for US DoD



Defense Information Systems Agency (DISA)
ATTN: Leonard F. Levine /Code EE31
P.O. Box 549
Ft. Meade, MD 20755-0549
Room A4B57D 
Telephone: 301-225-7497
Mobile: 703-861-4822
Classification:  UNCLASSIFIED 
Caveats: NONE




 smime.p7s