Issue 17290: Use of superSubType, wholePart and WholePartType in DoDAF 2 (updm-2-0-rtf) Source: Syntell AB (Mr Lars-Olof Kihlstrom, lars-olof.kihlstrom(at)syntell.se) Nature: Uncategorized Issue Severity: Summary: Use of superSubType, wholePart and WholePartType in DoDAF 2 DoDAF 2 contains rules that indicate that superSubtype relationships can be formed between any type elements of the same kind. The same rule applies for wholePart (betwen individuals of the same type) and WholePartType (between types of the same kind). In UPDM terms this would correspond to Generalization as well as property handling. There are not enough stereotypes defined within UPDM 2 to allow these rules to be followed. This either needs to be rectified or a general statement made within UPDM that allows the use of the appropriate UML relationships to accomplish this. Resolution: Revised Text: Actions taken: April 1, 2012: received issue Discussion: We have subset of these rules already in embedded in UPDM. It was decided to defer this issue based upon developments with the unification of the various frameworks Proposed Disposition: Deferred End of Annotations:===== m: Lars-Olof Kihlströ To: "issues@omg.org" Subject: Issues for UPDM 2.1 RTF Sir! The following issue also needs to be put on the RFT list Use of superSubType, wholePart and WholePartType in DoDAF 2 DoDAF 2 contains rules that indicate that superSubtype relationships can be formed between any type elements of the same kind. The same rule applies for wholePart (betwen individuals of the same type) and WholePartType (between types of the same kind). In UPDM terms this would correspond to Generalization as well as property handling. There are not enough stereotypes defined within UPDM 2 to allow these rules to be followed. This either needs to be rectified or a general statement made within UPDM that allows the use of the appropriate UML relationships to accomplish this. I would be very grateful if this could be aded to the list. Best regards Lars-Olof _________________________________________ Generic Systems Sweden AB Lars-Olof KihlströM.Sc. Eng Phys. Senior consultant P.O.Box 4023 . SE-131 04 Nacka . Sweden Visiting address: Augustendalstorget 3 Phone: +46 (0)8 601 38 00 Mobile: +46 (0)706 661978 Email: lars-olof.kihlstrom@generic.se