Issue 17533: Year of Weeks and Year of Weekdays Scales are Misdefined (dtv-rtf)
Source: International Business Machines (Mr. Mark H. Linehan, mlinehan(at)us.ibm.com)
Nature: Uncategorized Issue
Severity: 
Summary: Summary: 
These two ‘year of weeks scale’ and ‘year of weekdays scale’ are defined using the ‘time scale subdivides time point’ verb concept.  That verb concept assumes that the start of the time point coincides with the start of the scale, but this is not true for these two scales because calendar weeks are not coherent with calendar years.  A special verb concept needs to be used to relate weeks and weekdays to calendar years.

Resolution: The Date-Time FTF-2 did not have time to take up this issue.  It is a minor concern since it affects only the comparison of dates expressed using the weeks calendar with dates expressed using the Gregorian calendar.  It does not affect the primary concepts of the specification.  Consequently, the issue is deferred.
Revised Text: 
Disposition:	Deferred

Revised Text: 
Actions taken:
July 30, 2012: received issue
April 1, 2013: transferred from FTF
Discussion: 

End of Annotations:=====
sposition:    ???   
	OMG Issue No:  17533 
Title:	Year of Weeks and Year of Weekdays Scales are Misdefined
Source: Mark H. Linehan, IBM, mlinehan@us.ibm.com

Summary: 
These two .year of weeks scale. and .year of weekdays scale. are defined using the .time scale subdivides time point. verb concept.  That verb concept assumes that the start of the time point coincides with the start of the scale, but this is not true for these two scales because calendar weeks are not coherent with calendar years.  A special verb concept needs to be used to relate weeks and weekdays to calendar years.

Resolution:  
Revised Text: 
Disposition:	???