Issue 18044: Location: 18.1.1 Summary P. 685 - A Subject may only refer to a single system (uml25-ftf) Source: Soluta.net (Dr. Adriano Comai, acomai(at)soluta.net) Nature: Clarification Severity: Minor Summary: current text: “A UseCase’s subject represents the system or systems under consideration to which the UseCase applies.” [AC] This addition wasn't in the previous UML version, 11-08-06, where the description was “The subject is the system under consideration to which the use cases apply.” I consider the plural “or systems” ambiguous, because it lets the reader think that the subject may refer to more than a single system. If we want to say that the subject may be a very complex one, such as a system of systems (and this may be indeed useful in my opinion) we should state this point explicitly. So I suggest to go back to the previous formulation, or to state more explicitly that the subject may refer to an arbitrarily complex system Resolution: Revised Text: Actions taken: September 28, 2012: received issue Discussion: Perhaps the current text was trying to get at the fact that a UseCase may have more than one subject, each one representing a system to which the UseCase applies End of Annotations:===== s is issue # 18044 Problem: 18.003 Severity: Minor Type: Clarification Location: 18.1.1 Summary P. 685 Title: A Subject may only refer to a single system Description: current text: .A UseCase.s subject represents the system or systems under consideration to which the UseCase applies.. [AC] This addition wasn't in the previous UML version, 11-08-06, where the description was .The subject is the system under consideration to which the use cases apply.. I consider the plural .or systems. ambiguous, because it lets the reader think that the subject may refer to more than a single system. If we want to say that the subject may be a very complex one, such as a system of systems (and this may be indeed useful in my opinion) we should state this point explicitly. So I suggest to go back to the previous formulation, or to state more explicitly that the subject may refer to an arbitrarily complex system. Source: Adriano Comai Discussion: Perhaps the current text was trying to get at the fact that a UseCase may have more than one subject, each one representing a system to which the UseCase applies Michael Jesse Chonoles