Issue 5422: Chapter 3, Section 4.1.4.4 "Notification" pg 226, 227 (uml-edoc-ftf)
Source: Distributed Models Pty Ltd (Mr. Keith Duddy, keith.duddy(at)gmail.com)
Nature: Uncategorized Issue
Severity: 
Summary: It's not explained clearly what is in the PubSubNotice and what is in 
the EventNotice. i.e. a bullet list of data to be included in an 
EventNotice is given on page 227, but some of this may be included in 
every PubSubNotice (EventNotice's supertype). Both of these types are 
simply Attribute collections (CompositeData). 4.2.2.4 "EventNotice" 
gives no information about how this information is transmitted. 


Also: 4.2.2.4 "Related Elements" also wrongly includes inheritance.


Suggested Resolution: Clarify what data is included in a PubSub notice, 
and what is only in its subtype, EventNotice, and how. (In 4.2.2.4)
Perhaps we even need some specific attributes to standardise the names
and types of the data that are given in the bullet list of pg 227.


Resolution: 
Revised Text: 
Actions taken:
June 13, 2002: received issue
Discussion: 

End of Annotations:=====
X-Mailer: exmh version 2.5 07/13/2001 with nmh-1.0.4 
To: issues@omg.org 
Subject: EDOC Issue 
X-face:
*A\_v+D,~Jx_g]`m,s61-x|*;H4hgZeE=<s8=ep^q96kcoR,N|3]/;|F"C);wi^I6"-X}\# 
 NxV@i.&hb;o3+@m{cTE\D;uA&N`N2kHXc"<\2N8-+GJJSsAk3DcF6I@fM8[k,t$)^*YO=1F)A&[+-m 
  Jivdt{kFM4&a"}5Mi08HK6J8\W!tYX//<Jr4nX"u~65X0<R5172|K7-I"9/HcB}ENVsBq{lq 
Date: Thu, 13 Jun 2002 17:31:14 +1000 
From: Keith Duddy <dud@dstc.edu.au> 
X-Scanned-By: MIMEDefang 1.0
(http://www.roaringpenguin.com/mimedefang/) 


Chapter 3, Section 4.1.4.4 "Notification" pg 226, 227


It's not explained clearly what is in the PubSubNotice and what is in 
the EventNotice. i.e. a bullet list of data to be included in an 
EventNotice is given on page 227, but some of this may be included in 
every PubSubNotice (EventNotice's supertype). Both of these types are 
simply Attribute collections (CompositeData). 4.2.2.4 "EventNotice" 
gives no information about how this information is transmitted. 


Also: 4.2.2.4 "Related Elements" also wrongly includes inheritance.


Suggested Resolution: Clarify what data is included in a PubSub
notice, 
and what is only in its subtype, EventNotice, and how. (In 4.2.2.4)
Perhaps we even need some specific attributes to standardise the names
and types of the data that are given in the bullet list of pg 227.


|<
--
[[[[=================================================================]]]]
Keith Duddy  : dud at dstc.edu.au  :
http://www.dstc.edu.au/AU/staff/dud
       CRC for Enterprise Distributed Systems Technology (DSTC)
   General Purpose South, University of Queensland, 4072, Australia
            ph: +61 7 336 5 4310  ::  fx: +61 7 336 5 4311
                    DSTC is the Australian W3C Office
[[[[[[[[[[[[=================================================]]]]]]]]]]]]
        EDOC 2002 Conference    :     http://edocconference.org
6th IEEE International Enterprise Distributed Object Computing
Conference
                        September 17-20, 2002
[[[[=================================================================]]]