Issue 5524: Uses Relationships (components-ftf)
Source: Raytheon (Mr. Gerald Lee Bickle, Gerald.L.Bickle(at)raytheon.com)
Nature: Uncategorized Issue
Severity: 
Summary: The softpkg element only deals with deployed on and library load dependency
relationships for implementations. Component implementations may also have
specific using relationships with another component, such as a device
within the
system. This relationship can be stated at the softpkg or implementation
level.


Current Format


<!ELEMENT softpkg
( title
| pkgtype
| author
| description
| license
| idl
| propertyfile
| dependency
| descriptor
| implementation
| extension
)* >
<!ATTLIST softpkg
name ID #REQUIRED
version CDATA #IMPLIED >


<!ELEMENT implementation
( description
| code
| compiler
| dependency
| descriptor
| extension
| programminglanguage
| humanlanguage
| os
| propertyfile
| processor
| runtime
)* >
<!ATTLIST implementation
id ID #IMPLIED
variation CDATA #IMPLIED >


New Format


<!ELEMENT softpkg
( title
| pkgtype
| author
| description
| license
| idl
| propertyfile
| dependency
| descriptor
| implementation
| extension
| usescomponent
)* >
<!ATTLIST softpkg
name ID #REQUIRED
version CDATA #IMPLIED >


<!ELEMENT implementation
( description
| code
| compiler
| dependency
| descriptor
| extension
| programminglanguage
| humanlanguage
| os
| propertyfile
| processor
| runtime
| usescomponent
)* >
<!ATTLIST implementation
id ID #IMPLIED
variation CDATA #IMPLIED >


<!ELEMENT  usescomponent
     ( artifactdependency+
     )>
<!ATTLIST usescomponent
     id        ID               #REQUIRED
     type      CDATA     #REQUIRED>


<!ELEMENT artifactdependency EMPTY>
<!ATTLIST artifactdependency
artifactrefid       CDATA     #REQUIRED
artifactvalue       CDATA     #REQUIRED>


Note: This concept is tied to the concept of component artifact property
issue. The
artifactrefid is a reference to a component's artifact property defined in
a
component's property file. The artifactvalue is the dependency value being
requested or needed.


Resolution: 
Revised Text: 
Actions taken:
July 17, 2002: received issue
Discussion: 
Resolution:
None as this is deferred to the final report of the Components 1.1 RTF.
Revised Text:
None as this is deferred to the final report of the Components 1.1 RTF

End of Annotations:=====
From: Gerald_L_Bickle@RAYTHEON.COM 
Subject: CCM Softpkg DTD Extensions & Changes 
To: issues@omg.org, components-rtf@omg.org 
Cc: "Mike McClimens" <mikemc@mitre.org>, "Smith, Jeff"
<jesmith@mc.com>, 
   Edwin.Wrench@ITT.COM, mike.mcclimens@saalt.army.mil, 
   "Mike McClimens" <mikemc@mitre.org>, 
   David Fitkin <dwfitkin@rockwellcollins.com>,
   jeffrey.olynick@baesystems.com 
X-Mailer: Lotus Notes Release 5.0.8  June 18, 2001 
Date: Wed, 17 Jul 2002 12:57:08 -0500 
X-MIMETrack: Serialize by Router on NotesServer3/HDC(Release 5.0.8
|June 18, 2001) at 07/17/2002 
 12:57:09 PM 
X-MIME-Autoconverted: from quoted-printable to 8bit by emerald.omg.org
id g6HHsWC06347 


Document ptc/2001-11-03, CORBA Component Model


11.  Uses Relationships
The softpkg element only deals with deployed on and library load
dependency
relationships for implementations. Component implementations may also
have
specific using relationships with another component, such as a device
within the
system. This relationship can be stated at the softpkg or
implementation
level.


Current Format


<!ELEMENT softpkg
( title
| pkgtype
| author
| description
| license
| idl
| propertyfile
| dependency
| descriptor
| implementation
| extension
)* >
<!ATTLIST softpkg
name ID #REQUIRED
version CDATA #IMPLIED >


<!ELEMENT implementation
( description
| code
| compiler
| dependency
| descriptor
| extension
| programminglanguage
| humanlanguage
| os
| propertyfile
| processor
| runtime
)* >
<!ATTLIST implementation
id ID #IMPLIED
variation CDATA #IMPLIED >


New Format


<!ELEMENT softpkg
( title
| pkgtype
| author
| description
| license
| idl
| propertyfile
| dependency
| descriptor
| implementation
| extension
| usescomponent
)* >
<!ATTLIST softpkg
name ID #REQUIRED
version CDATA #IMPLIED >


<!ELEMENT implementation
( description
| code
| compiler
| dependency
| descriptor
| extension
| programminglanguage
| humanlanguage
| os
| propertyfile
| processor
| runtime
| usescomponent
)* >
<!ATTLIST implementation
id ID #IMPLIED
variation CDATA #IMPLIED >


<!ELEMENT  usescomponent
     ( artifactdependency+
     )>
<!ATTLIST usescomponent
     id        ID               #REQUIRED
     type      CDATA     #REQUIRED>


<!ELEMENT artifactdependency EMPTY>
<!ATTLIST artifactdependency
artifactrefid       CDATA     #REQUIRED
artifactvalue       CDATA     #REQUIRED>


Note: This concept is tied to the concept of component artifact
property
issue. The
artifactrefid is a reference to a component's artifact property
defined in
a
component's property file. The artifactvalue is the dependency value
being
requested or needed.



-------Summary of Proposed Changes-----------------


<!ELEMENT author
     ( name*
     , company?
     , webpage?
)>



<!ELEMENT artifactdependency EMPTY>
<!ATTLIST artifactdependency
artifactrefid  CDATA     #REQUIRED
artifactvalue  CDATA     #REQUIRED>



<!ELEMENT code
( ( codebase
| fileinarchive
| link
)
, entrypoint?
, stacksize?
     , priority?
, usage?
) >
<!ATTLIST code
type CDATA #IMPLIED >


<!ELEMENT dependency
( softpkgref
| codebase
| fileinarchive
| localfile
| name
| valuetypefactory
)
, artifactdependency*
>
<!ATTLIST dependency
type CDATA #IMPLIED
action (assert | install)"assert">


<!ELEMENT deviceartifactdependency EMPTY>
<!ATTLIST deviceartifactdependency
     artifactrefid       CDATA     #REQUIRED
artifactvalue       CDATA     #REQUIRED>


<!ELEMENT implementation
( description?
     , code
     , compiler?
     , license?
     , humanlanguage?
     , programminglanguage?
     , propertyfile?
     , (  dependency
       | descriptor
       | deviceartifactdependency
            | extension
       | idl
       | os
       | processor
       | runtime
       | usescomponent
       )*
     )>
<!ATTLIST implementation
id ID #IMPLIED
variation CDATA #IMPLIED >


<!ELEMENT softpkg
      (  title?
     , author+
     , description?
     , propertyfile?
     , license?
     , pkgtype?
     , implementation+
     , (   idl
       | dependency
       | descriptor
       | extension
       | usescomponent
     )*
     )>
<!ATTLIST softpkg
     name      ID   #REQUIRED
     version        CDATA     #IMPLIED >


<!ELEMENT priority (#PCDATA)>


<!ELEMENT stacksize (#PCDATA)>


<!ELEMENT  usescomponent
     ( artifactdependency+
     )>
<!ATTLIST usescomponent
     id        ID   #REQUIRED
     type      CDATA     #REQUIRED