Issue 5858: CCM IDL style inconsistency (components-ftf)
Source:  (, )
Nature: Uncategorized Issue
Severity: 
Summary: * document : formal/02-06-65
* chapter  : 1.5.2.4


* text in question :


module Components 
{ 
  valuetype Cookie 
  {
    private CORBA::OctetSeq cookieValue; 
  }; 
};


* Issues : 


 1. Naming style used in this definition violates rules defined in 
    "OMG IDL Style Guide" (ab/98-06-03).


 2. Naming style used in this definition is inconsistent with other parts
    of the CCM IDL, for example:


module Components 
{ 
  valuetype PortDescription
  {
    public FeatureName name;
    public CORBA::RepositoryId type_id;
  };
    
  valuetype FacetDescription : PortDescription
  {
    public Object facet_ref;
  };
}


* suggested resolution : replace `cookieValue' with `cookie_value'



Resolution: 
Revised Text: 
Actions taken:
February 12, 2003: received issue
Discussion: 

End of Annotations:=====
Date: Wed, 12 Feb 2003 15:01:17 -0600 
From: Boris Kolpackov <boris@isis-server.isis.vanderbilt.edu> 
To: components-ftf@omg.org 
Cc: juergen@omg.org 
Subject: CCM IDL style inconsistency 
User-Agent: Mutt/1.3.28i 
X-Mailer: mutt 
X-Uptime: 18:50 
X-URL: http://www.kolpackov.net/ 
X-Accept-Language: en, ru 
X-Location: USA, TN, Nashville 


Good day,



* document : formal/02-06-65
* chapter  : 1.5.2.4


* text in question :


module Components 
{ 
  valuetype Cookie 
  {
    private CORBA::OctetSeq cookieValue; 
  }; 
};


* Issues : 


 1. Naming style used in this definition violates rules defined in 
    "OMG IDL Style Guide" (ab/98-06-03).


 2. Naming style used in this definition is inconsistent with other
    parts
    of the CCM IDL, for example:


module Components 
{ 
  valuetype PortDescription
  {
    public FeatureName name;
    public CORBA::RepositoryId type_id;
  };
    
  valuetype FacetDescription : PortDescription
  {
    public Object facet_ref;
  };
}


* suggested resolution : replace `cookieValue' with `cookie_value'


thanks,
-bori