Issue 6087: Figure 346 needs updating (uml2-superstructure-ftf) Source: SINTEF (Dr. Oystein Haugen, oystein.haugen(at)sintef.no) Nature: Clarification Severity: Minor Summary: The Figure 346 on page 443 needs some updating: 1. The collaboration W should be shown as an oval 2. The text inside the right lifeline of sd Q should read “y:superB” (the colon is missing) Resolution: see above Revised Text: Actions taken: August 29, 2003: received issue March 8, 2005: closed issue Discussion: Change the solid ellipse with name “w1:W” in the bottom part of the class diagram for “E” into a dashed ellipse (page 161, chapter 9, notation for CollaborationOccurences: “A collaboration occurrence is shown by a dashed ellipse”). Change the solid line representing binding of “:B” as role “y” into a dashed line (page 161, chapter 9, “for every role binding, there is a dashed line from the ellipse to the client element”) Leave the definition of the collaboration as a generic classifier symbol with a stereotype <<collaboration>> so that the reusable seque nce diagram is nicely placed into the middle (attributes) compartment. Do not use the special collaboration symbol (a dashed ellipse, page161), since no examples in chapter 9 illustrate the notation for placing reusable classifiers into these symbols. The generic composite structure notation is fine. Change the text “ysuperB” into “y:superB” (however, this part is a duplicate of the issue 6950, already resolved) End of Annotations:===== From: webmaster@omg.org Date: 28 Aug 2003 03:07:24 -0400 To: Subject: Issue/Bug Report -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Name: Oystein Haugen Company: Ericsson mailFrom: oystein.haugen@ericsson.com Notification: Yes Specification: UML 2.0 Superstructure Section: 14.4 FormalNumber: ptc/03-08-02 Version: 2.0 RevisionDate: August 2003 Page: 443 Nature: Clarification Severity: Minor HTTP User Agent: Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Windows NT 5.0) Description Figure 346 needs updating The Figure 346 on page 443 needs some updating: 1. The collaboration W should be shown as an oval 2. The text inside the right lifeline of sd Q should read Ţły:superBŢ´ (the colon is missing) OMG Issue No: 6087 Title: Figure 346 needs updating Source: Ericsson (Dr. Oystein Haugen, oystein.haugen@ericsson.no oystein.haugen@ericsson.com Oystein.Haugen@eto.ericsson.se) Summary: The Figure 346 on page 443 needs some updating: 1. The collaboration W should be shown as an oval 2. The text inside the right lifeline of sd Q should read .y:superB. (the colon is missing) Discussion: Change the solid ellipse with name .w1:W. in the bottom part of the class diagram for .E. into a dashed ellipse (page 161, chapter 9, notation for CollaborationOccurences: .A collaboration occurrence is shown by a dashed ellipse.). Change the solid line representing binding of .:B. as role .y. into a dashed line (page 161, chapter 9, .for every role binding, there is a dashed line from the ellipse to the client element.) Leave the definition of the collaboration as a generic classifier symbol with a stereotype <> so that the reusable sequence diagram is nicely placed into the middle (attributes) compartment. Do not use the special collaboration symbol (a dashed ellipse, page161), since no examples in chapter 9 illustrate the notation for placing reusable classifiers into these symbols. The generic composite structure notation is fine. Change the text .ysuperB. into .y:superB. (however, this part is a duplicate of the issue 6950, already resolved) Disposition: Resolved