Issue 6994: 'CORBA to WSDL/SOAP Section 1.2.8.2                                                                                                                                                                     (corbawsdl-ftf)
Source:  (, )
Nature: Uncategorized Issue
Severity: 
Summary: Section 1.2.8.2
In the example:
<message name="CORBA.SystemExceptionMessage" >
<part name="_return" type="CORBA.SystemException"/>
</message>
CORBA Specification says that CORBA Exception cannot be passed as paramters or return value. But the example seems to ¡°return¡± a SystemException.
Proposed solution: Maybe the example should be defined as the following according to the exception mapping rules:
<message name="CORBA.SystemExceptionMessage" >
<part name="exception" type="CORBA.SystemException"/>
</message>


Resolution: Close with no change.  While confusing, the use of "_return" for the name is not invalid
Revised Text: 
Actions taken:
February 19, 2004: received issue
March 10, 2005: closed issue
Discussion: 

End of Annotations:=====
te: Thu, 19 Feb 2004 14:54:02 +0800 (CST) 
From: =?gb2312?q?bin=20zhou?= <hncszhoubin@yahoo.com.cn> 
Subject: issue reporting (3-1) 
To: issues@omg.org 


Hi,there
 
We are OMG Uni. member (Member ID: 45687).
 
We have found a issue/bug for the 'CORBA to WSDL/SOAP Interworking Specification' (03-11-02). Posted below.
 
----------------------------------------------------------
Name: Bin Zhou 
Company: National Lab. on Distributed Processing
mailFrom: http://cn.f153.mail.yahoo.com/ym/Compose?To=hncszhoubin@yahoo.com.cn
Specification: CORBA to WSDL/SOAP Interworking Specification 
 
Section 1.2.8.2
In the example:
<message name="CORBA.SystemExceptionMessage" >
<part name="_return" type="CORBA.SystemException"/>
</message>
CORBA Specification says that CORBA Exception cannot be passed as paramters or return value. But the example seems to ¡°return¡± a SystemException.
Proposed solution: Maybe the example should be defined as the following according to the exception mapping rules:
<message name="CORBA.SystemExceptionMessage" >
<part name="exception" type="CORBA.SystemException"/>
</message>
-------------------------------------------------------------
 
best regards,
 
Bin




--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Do You Yahoo!?


Date: Sat, 02 Oct 2004 14:35:43 -0400 
From: Tom Rutt <tom@coastin.com> 
Reply-To: tom@coastin.com 
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1; en-US; rv:1.7.3) Gecko/20040910 
X-Accept-Language: en-us, en 
To: wsdlcorba-rtf@omg.org 
CC: "Moore, Keith (HP Labs)" <keith.moore@hp.com>, 
   "Vinoski, Stephen" <Steve.Vinoski@iona.com>, iwasa <kiwasa@jp.fujitsu.com> 
Subject: Plea to vote no on wsdlCorba RTF Issue 6994 


On reflection, I have determined that we should vote no on the resolution to Issue 6994.


While the use of the part name "_return" is confusing for the contents of CORBA.SystemExceptionMessage, it is not
invalid. Changing anything in the corba namespace for this spec will have terrible backwards compatibility problems


We should just keep the part name as "_return" in this one CORBA.SystemExceptionMessage.


I urge all members to vote no on the proposed resolution for Issue 6994


Tom Rutt
Fujitsu



--------------------
Issue 6994: 'CORBA to WSDL/SOAP Section 1.2.8.2 (corbawsdl-ftf)


Click here for this issue's archive.




Source: National Lab, Distributed Process, China (Dr. Bin Zhou, hncszhoubin@yahoo.com.cn)




Nature: Uncategorized Issue




Severity:




Summary: CORBA to WSDL/SOAP Interworking Specification




Section 1.2.8.2


In the example:






<message name="CORBA.SystemExceptionMessage" >


<part name="_return" type="CORBA.SystemException"/>


</message>






CORBA Specification says that CORBA Exception cannot be passed as parameters or return value.


But the example seems to return a SystemException.


Proposed solution: Maybe the example should be defined as the following according to the


exception mapping rules:




<message name="CORBA.SystemExceptionMessage" >


<part name="exception" type="CORBA.SystemException"/>


</message>






Proposed Resolution: Accept proposal from source, consistent with user defined exceptions in 1.2.8.5


Revised Text: In section 1.2.8.2:


Change, on page 1-20


Íêsage name="CORBA.SystemExceptionMessage" >


<part name="_return" type="CORBA.SystemException"/>


</message>


.


to:


.


<message name="CORBA.SystemExceptionMessage" >


<part name="exception" type="CORBA.SystemException"/>


</message>


.


----------------------------------------------------
Tom Rutt        email: tom@coastin.com; trutt@us.fujitsu.com
Tel: +1 732 801 5744          Fax: +1 732 774 5133

«Ãâ·ÑµÄÑÅ»¢µçÓÊ£¬ÂíÉÏ×¢²á»ñÔù¶îÍâ60Õ×ÍøÂç´æ´¢¿Õ¼ä