Issue 7941: Resource Deployment Description Insufficient                                                                                                                                                            (deployment-rtf)
Source: Mercury Computer Systems (Mr. Frank Pilhofer, fpilhofe@mc.com)
Nature: Uncategorized Issue
Severity: 
Summary: In section 6.8.9, the ResourceDeploymentDescription, part of a
DeploymentPlan, contains information about the resources that were
chosen to satisfy a requirement.


It has a "resourceValue" association to an Any value.


However, resources and requirements have not just one value, but a
set of properties; see 6.10.4 (RequirementSatisfier) and 6.10.7
(Requirement).


Therefore, the "resourceValue" must be replaced with a set of
"Properties" elements.


Proposed resolution:


In section 6.8.9.3 (ResourceDeploymentDescription associations),
replace the current association


  resourceValue: Any [1]
        The aspect of the resource actually allocated, if any, of
        the appropriate type of the resource's SatisfierPropertyKind
        attribute. For Quantity, it is the ordinal allocated. For
        Allocation, it is the allocated capacity, for Selection, it
        is the matched string. For others, it is the value of the
        matched property.


with


  property: Property [*]
        The aspects of the resource actually allocated, if any. The
        property values are of the appropriate types according to
        their matched SatisfierProperty's SatisfierPropertyKind
        attribute. For Quantity, it is the ordinal allocated. For
        Allocation, it is the allocated capacity, for Selection, it
        is the matched string. For others, it is the value of the
        matched property
Resolution: 
Revised Text: In section 6.8.9.3 (ResourceDeploymentDescription associations), replace the current association

    resourceValue: Any [1]
        The aspect of the resource actually allocated, if any, of
        the appropriate type of the resource's SatisfierPropertyKind
        attribute. For Quantity, it is the ordinal allocated. For
        Allocation, it is the allocated capacity, for Selection, it
        is the matched string. For others, it is the value of the
        matched property.

with

    property: Property [*]
        The aspects of the resource actually allocated, if any. The
        property values are of the appropriate types according to
        their matched SatisfierProperty's SatisfierPropertyKind
        attribute. For Quantity, it is the ordinal allocated. For
        Allocation, it is the allocated capacity, for Selection, it
        is the matched string. For others, it is the value of the
        matched property

Actions taken:
November 19, 2004: received issue
May 9, 2005: closed issue
Discussion: 
Resolution:
Change the text as proposed

End of Annotations:=====
ubject: Resource Deployment Description Insufficient 
Date: Fri, 19 Nov 2004 14:22:38 -0500 
Thread-Topic: Resource Deployment Description Insufficient 
Thread-Index: AcTObSE+8Chbau9NQNW0w7TRHC8ebw== 
From: "Pilhofer, Frank" <fpilhofe@mc.com> 
To: <issues@omg.org> 
Cc: "Deployment RTF" <deployment-rtf@omg.org> 
X-MIME-Autoconverted: from quoted-printable to 8bit by amethyst.omg.org id iAJJkQ1U009506 


This is a new issue with the Deployment RTF.


In section 6.8.9, the ResourceDeploymentDescription, part of a
DeploymentPlan, contains information about the resources that were
chosen to satisfy a requirement.


It has a "resourceValue" association to an Any value.


However, resources and requirements have not just one value, but a
set of properties; see 6.10.4 (RequirementSatisfier) and 6.10.7
(Requirement).


Therefore, the "resourceValue" must be replaced with a set of
"Properties" elements.


Proposed resolution:


In section 6.8.9.3 (ResourceDeploymentDescription associations),
replace the current association


  resourceValue: Any [1]
        The aspect of the resource actually allocated, if any, of
        the appropriate type of the resource's SatisfierPropertyKind
        attribute. For Quantity, it is the ordinal allocated. For
        Allocation, it is the allocated capacity, for Selection, it
        is the matched string. For others, it is the value of the
        matched property.


with


  property: Property [*]
        The aspects of the resource actually allocated, if any. The
        property values are of the appropriate types according to
        their matched SatisfierProperty's SatisfierPropertyKind
        attribute. For Quantity, it is the ordinal allocated. For
        Allocation, it is the allocated capacity, for Selection, it
        is the matched string. For others, it is the value of the
        matched property.