Issue 8523: webservice profile incorrect connection with component profile (ras-ftf) Source: International Business Machines (Mr. Grant Larsen, gjlarsen@us.ibm.com) Nature: Uncategorized Issue Severity: Summary: Section 7.7.5 of the spec related to the RAS webservice profile indicates that there is still a relationship between RAS component and RAS webservice profiles. "Only the new elements for this profile are outlined here. For information on other elements refer to this profile's ancestry, namely the Default Component profile and the Default profile." This is no longer true...but more importantly however...is the fact that the current webservice profile ID still includes the component's profile ID in it's parent chain. The text in the spec needs to be updated remove association and the id history for the webservice profile needs to be updated to remove the connection to the component profile. We propose to update the Profile.id-history attribute as follows. Current webservice profile id-history: F1C842AD-CE85-4261-ACA7-178C457018A1::31E5BFBF-B16E-4253-8037-98D70D07F35F::1025A790-78D4-4f57-94CE-E65B23275FCD::710CA9C5-CA9C-4be2-BB1A-D23677C62A4C Revised webservice profile id-history, after removing the Component profile id from the id-history: F1C842AD-CE85-4261-ACA7-178C457018A1::31E5BFBF-B16E-4253-8037-98D70D07F35F:: 710CA9C5-CA9C-4be2-BB1A-D23677C62A4C Resolution: Revised Text: In section 7.7.1 we propose to update the Profile.id-history attribute and the related-profile attribute with the proper IDs to remove the relationship to the Default Component profile, as follows. Current Default Webservice profile id-history: <rasprofile:profile name="Default Web Service" id="F1C842AD-CE85-4261-ACA7-178C457018A1::31E5BFBF-B16E-4253-8037-98D70D07F35F::1025A790-78D4-4f57-94CE-E65B23275FCD::710CA9C5-CA9C-4be2-BB1A-D23677C62A4C" version-major="1" version-minor="11" parent="1025A790-78D4-4f57-94CE-E65B23275FCD"> Revised Default Webservice profile id-history, after removing the Default Component profile id from the id-history: <rasprofile:profile name="Default Web Service" idhistory="F1C842AD-CE85-4261-ACA7-178C457018A1::31E5BFBF-B16E-4253-8037-98D70D07F35F::710CA9C5-CA9C-4be2-BB1A-D23677C62A4C" version-major="1" version-minor="11"> Current Default Webservice profile related-profile: <rasprofile:description>This is the first major version of the default webservice profile. This profile can be accepted by XDE release 2 and later.</rasprofile:description> <rasprofile:related-profile name="Default Component" id="1025A790-78D4-4f57-94CE-E65B23275FCD" version-major="1" version-minor="11" parent="31E5BFBF-B16E-4253-8037-98D70D07F35F">This is the first major version of the default component profile. This profile can be accepted by XDE release 2 and later.</ rasprofile:related-profile> <rasprofile:related-profile name="Default" id="31E5BFBF-B16E-4253-8037-98D70D07F35F" version-major="2" version-minor="01" parent="F1C842AD-CE85-4261-ACA7-178C457018A1">This is the second major version of the default profile. This profile can be accepted by XDE release 2 and later.</rasprofile:related-profile> <rasprofile:related-profile name="Core" id="F1C842AD-CE85-4261-ACA7-178C457018A1" version-major="1" version-minor="0" parent="">The original base of Core RAS.</rasprofile:related-profile> </rasprofile:profile> Revised Default Webservice profile related-profile (note the strikethrough is only to illustrate what will be deleted): <rasprofile:description>This is the first major version of the default webservice profile. This profile can be accepted by XDE release 2 and later.</rasprofile:description> <rasprofile:related-profile name="Default Component" id="1025A790-78D4-4f57-94CE-E65B23275FCD" version-major="1" version-minor="11" parent="31E5BFBF-B16E-4253-8037-98D70D07F35F">This is the first major version of the default component profile. This profile can be accepted by XDE release 2 and later.</ rasprofile:related-profile> <rasprofile:related-profile name="Default" id="31E5BFBF-B16E-4253-8037-98D70D07F35F" version-major="2" version-minor="01" parent="F1C842AD-CE85-4261-ACA7-178C457018A1">This is the second major version of the default profile. This profile can be accepted by XDE release 2 and later.</rasprofile:related-profile> <rasprofile:related-profile name="Core" id="F1C842AD-CE85-4261-ACA7-178C457018A1" version-major="1" version-minor="0" parent="">The original base of Core RAS.</rasprofile:related-profile> </rasprofile:profile> Actions taken: March 9, 2005: received issue August 1, 2005: closed issue Discussion: End of Annotations:===== ubject: RAS FTF: webservice profile incorrect connection with component profile X-Mailer: Lotus Notes Release 6.0.2CF1 June 9, 2003 From: Grant J Larsen Date: Tue, 8 Mar 2005 22:26:48 -0700 X-MIMETrack: Serialize by Router on D03NM118/03/M/IBM(Build V70_M4_01112005 Beta 3|January 11, 2005) at 03/08/2005 22:26:49, Serialize complete at 03/08/2005 22:26:49 Section 7.7.5 of the spec related to the RAS webservice profile indicates that there is still a relationship between RAS component and RAS webservice profiles. "Only the new elements for this profile are outlined here. For information on other elements refer to this profile's ancestry, namely the Default Component profile and the Default profile." This is no longer true...but more importantly however...is the fact that the current webservice profile ID still includes the component's profile ID in it's parent chain. The text in the spec needs to be updated remove association and the id history for the webservice profile needs to be updated to remove the connection to the component profile. We propose to update the Profile.id-history attribute as follows. Current webservice profile id-history: F1C842AD-CE85-4261-ACA7-178C457018A1::31E5BFBF-B16E-4253-8037-98D70D07F35F::1025A790-78D4-4f57-94CE-E65B23275FCD::710CA9C5-CA9C-4be2-BB1A-D23677C62A4C Revised webservice profile id-history, after removing the Component profile id from the id-history: F1C842AD-CE85-4261-ACA7-178C457018A1::31E5BFBF-B16E-4253-8037-98D70D07F35F:: 710CA9C5-CA9C-4be2-BB1A-D23677C62A4C Thanks, Grant ----------------------------------------------------------- Grant Larsen STSM IBM Rational software Voice: (303) 932-7368 Mobile: (303) 601-1257 Fax: (303) 932-6963 Notes: Grant J Larsen/Denver/IBM E-mail: gjlarsen@us.ibm.com