Issue 9954: Page: 13-14 ++ (sbvr-ftf) Source: Business Semantics Ltd. (Mr. Donald R. Chapin, Donald.Chapin(at)BusinessSemantics.com) Nature: Revision Severity: Critical Summary: ISSUE: "SBVR 'Thing' <-> 'Expression' Architecture" Needs Fixing 1. Form for Representation needs to be added between 'meaning' and 'representation' to include 'semantic formulations; forms of concept meaning (intensional, extensional,etc.); types of forms of expression. 2. 'Representation' should to tie to 'form of representaiton' instead to directly to meaning and add should only Speech Community considerations (language, Speech Community-specific terms, notations) to 'form of representation'. 3. 'Expression is in Language' needs to be added 4. Representations, at least designations, should be in canonical form 5. The relationship between 'representation' and 'expression' should allow for basic linguistic analysis e.g. multiple spellings, plurals, etc. Resolution: Deferred to second SBVR Revision Task Force because there were more foundational issues that had to be resolved first, and it was very important SBVR v1.1 out as soon as they were done. Disposition: Deferred Revised Text: Actions taken: July 24, 2006: received issue Discussion: This Issue was received just before the Issue deadline which was only 6 weeks before the FTF report was due, and more basic Issues had to be resolved first. End of Annotations:===== m: webmaster@omg.org Date: 24 Jul 2006 20:34:03 -0400 To: Subject: Issue/Bug Report -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Name: Donald Chapin Company: Business Semanitcs Ltd mailFrom: Donald.Chapin@btinternet.com Notification: No Specification: SBVR Section: 8 ++ FormalNumber: dtc/06-03-02 Version: Interim Specification RevisionDate: March 2006 Page: 13-14 ++ Nature: Revision Severity: Critical HTTP User Agent: Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Windows NT 5.1; SV1; .NET CLR 1.1.4322; InfoPath.1; .NET CLR 2.0.50727) Description ISSUE: "SBVR 'Thing' <-> 'Expression' Architecture" Needs Fixing 1. Form for Representation needs to be added between 'meaning' and 'representation' to include 'semantic formulations; forms of concept meaning (intensional, extensional,etc.); types of forms of expression. 2. 'Representation' should to tie to 'form of representaiton' instead to directly to meaning and add should only Speech Community considerations (language, Speech Community-specific terms, notations) to 'form of representation'. 3. 'Expression is in Language' needs to be added 4. Representations, at least designations, should be in canonical form 5. The relationship between 'representation' and 'expression' should allow for basic linguistic analysis e.g. multiple spellings, plurals, etc.