Issues for UML 2.2 Superstructure and Infrastructure Revision Task Force

To comment on any of these issues, send email to uml2-rtf@omg.org. (Please include the issue number in the Subject: header, thusly: [Issue ###].) To submit a new issue, send email to issues@omg.org.

List of issues (green=resolved, yellow=pending Board vote, red=unresolved)

List options: All ; Open Issues only; or Closed Issues only

Issue 3898: Specify XMI parameters for the UML / XMI interchange format
Issue 4448: Does visibility apply to creating an destroying links?
Issue 5794: Designates a Generalization
Issue 5804: 2.5.2.27 ModelElement
Issue 5896: logic upperbound is the same as the lower bound.
Issue 5907: formal/03-03-01 : Omission of definition of Class "Action"
Issue 6002: relationship should just be a cross-reference
Issue 6003: document appears to be inconsistent in how it handles concepts
Issue 6004: Relationship and DirectedRelationship in Core::Constructs
Issue 6005: cross-reference missing
Issue 6006: Classes diagram of the Core::Constructs package
Issue 6176: UML 2 Super/Metamodel::Constructs/owningComment
Issue 6187: UML 2 Super/Metamodel::Super/missing merge
Issue 6194: UML 2 Super/Package merge/redefinitions issue - lost association ends
Issue 6197: UML 2 Super/Metamodel::Kernel/missing merges
Issue 6201: UML 2 Infra/Metamodel::Constructs/invalid OCL constraint for "opposite"
Issue 6216: UML 2 Super/pg.75/kinds of changeability
Issue 6262: UML 2 Super / Templates / TemplateParameter not named
Issue 6275: raisedException
Issue 6389: Syntax of names
Issue 6398: UML 2 Super / Kernel features / cannot exclude superclass properties
Issue 6423: Section 9.3.4 page 161, Presentation Option
Issue 6444: Activity diagram problems
Issue 6446: Clarification of Information Flow semantics
Issue 6451: UML 2 Super / Dependency / ownership of dependencies
Issue 6456: Use 'represent' for the relationship of a model
Issue 6463: UML 2 Issue: Message notation
Issue 6492: ptc-03-09-15/Non-navigable ends with no role names nor multiplicities
Issue 6493: ptc-03-09-15/Constructs::Class superClass property
Issue 6496: ptc-03-09-15/Relationships among Core packages
Issue 6501: Rose Model of UML 2.0 spec
Issue 6502: Multiplicity seems to be broken - UML2 Infra & Super Why not using the UML1 activity symbol for UML2 actions?
Issue 6503: Why not using the UML1 activity symbol for UML2 actions?
Issue 6524: class "InfrastructureLibrary.core.constructs.Association",
Issue 6525: two classes "NamedElement
Issue 6630: UML 2 Super / Classes / dependencies should be unidirectional
Issue 6639: remove paragraph
Issue 6640: number of the figure is wrong
Issue 6641: well-formedness rules are not numbered correctly
Issue 6659: multiplicity of the association named "type" of type DataType
Issue 6660: The multiplicity of association named subaction of type Action ill formed
Issue 6661: In paragraph 5, the addition of 2, 5, 7 and -3 does not yield 9 but 11
Issue 6662: In the last paragraph, the period after the word "collections" on the secon
Issue 6665: UML 1.5 table of contents
Issue 6692: Operations and derived attributes
Issue 6696: Remove one of the dots between protectedAction and availableOutput
Issue 6697: Associations section of element JumpHandler
Issue 6699: UML 2.0 infra and super Constraints Diagram of the Kernel
Issue 6702: The numbering of the sub-sections in 2.7.2 is wrong
Issue 6703: In "2.9.3.5 Instance", numbering of different well-formedness rules wrong
Issue 6704: The section about Procedure does not contain any well-formedness rules
Issue 6724: The Composition section does not follow the usual conventions
Issue 6725: missing closing parenthesis
Issue 6726: At the bottom of the page, the characters "antics." should be removed
Issue 6727: In 2.13.3, the first sub-section about ActivityGraph is not numbered
Issue 6923: Class InfrastructureLibrary::Core::Basic::Property
Issue 6989: UML 2 Super/Interactions/Constraints for create messages
Issue 7105: In normative XMI file for the metamodel, no Associations have a name.
Issue 7274: UML2 Infra/11.5.1/Invalid reference to Attribute class
Issue 7343: Section 11.7
Issue 7362: Clarify example in figure 133
Issue 7397: add an interaction fragment
Issue 7401: XMI schema
Issue 7407: The specification is fond of using 'typically.'
Issue 7756: Unconsistent association extension description
Issue 7757: Unconsistent Profile extension description (02)
Issue 7782: Move Comment into Basic and add Kind
Issue 7783: Missing XMI tags in spec and XMI rendition of metamodel
Issue 7889: Inconsistent use of 'Element' between MOF and UML
Issue 7908: Design principles
Issue 7909: Problem with diagram references in Profiles section
Issue 7938: DataType attributes UML 2 Super (ptc/04-10-02)
Issue 7939: DataType attributes UML 2 Super (ptc/04-10-02)
Issue 7942: Section: 7.3.43
Issue 7946: Section: 7.2.8
Issue 7947: Classes
Issue 7948: section 2.10.4.1 detailed semantics of collaborations
Issue 7949: Section: 7.3.44 - OCL incorrect
Issue 7950: Interactions
Issue 7956: InfrastructureLibrary defines, but should not use package merge
Issue 7970: Minor error in BNF of an message argument
Issue 7973: UML 2 Super / Incorrect statement on port visibility
Issue 7977: ReduceAction
Issue 7986: Section: 14.3.7
Issue 7987: Section: 14.3.13
Issue 7988: Section: 14.3.14
Issue 7989: Section: 14.3.16
Issue 7990: Section: Table 14
Issue 7995: StateInvariants/Continuations
Issue 7996: Add concept "StateInvariant"
Issue 8015: Transitivity in composition
Issue 8017: Pin/parameter matching constraints
Issue 8018: Section: CB/ACT
Issue 8019: Section: Classes
Issue 8021: Section: Classes
Issue 8025: Associations between interfaces
Issue 8027: Connector multiplicity notation
Issue 8028: create dependency Figures 103 and 121
Issue 8030: Interactions chapter refers to ActivityInvocations
Issue 8031: Destruction semantics in StructuredClassifier
Issue 8032: Link maintenance in StructuredClassifier
Issue 8033: Figure 119 missing multiplicity
Issue 8035: Notation for method
Issue 8036: Preserve order in result of read actions
Issue 8037: Optional inputs
Issue 8038: IsReadOnly constriant
Issue 8039: DestroyObjectAction semantics
Issue 8040: ObjectNode, constraint 1 In ObjectNode
Issue 8041: StructuredActivityNode specialized multiplicity
Issue 8062: section 9.20.2 VisibilityKind lists two types of visibility
Issue 8063: Text references Figure 8 and the correct figure number is 6
Issue 8064: unclear statement
Issue 8065: extra word in the last sentence of the paragraph under Attributes
Issue 8066: clarify what a directed association is
Issue 8067: Section is badly worded and does not make a lot of sense
Issue 8068: typing error in the statement :unrestricted ?
Issue 8069: What happened to real numbers
Issue 8070: methods not defined under attributes
Issue 8072: Figure 68
Issue 8073: Section: 11.3.1
Issue 8074: Section: 11.3.3
Issue 8075: search for referenced item -- Section: 11.3.4
Issue 8076: Section: 11.5
Issue 8078: Actor is a specialized Classifier and not BehavioredClassifier
Issue 8079: Section: 11.6.1
Issue 8080: Section: 11.8.3
Issue 8081: Section: 13.1.2
Issue 8082: Section: 13.1.5
Issue 8083: Section: 7.3.3
Issue 8084: Section: 7.3.6
Issue 8085: Section: 7.4.1
Issue 8086: Section: 6.5.1: Error in example
Issue 8088: Section: 7.3.3
Issue 8089: Section: 7.3.8
Issue 8090: Section: 7.3.10
Issue 8091: Section: 7.3.12
Issue 8092: Section: 7.3.15
Issue 8093: Section: 7.3.20
Issue 8094: Stereotypes applying in UML 2.0
Issue 8095: Section: 7.3.22
Issue 8096: Section: 7.3.32
Issue 8097: Section: 7.3.32 Page: 96-99
Issue 8098: Section: 7.3.33
Issue 8099: Section: 7.3.34
Issue 8100: Section: 7.3.35
Issue 8103: Section: 8.3.1
Issue 8104: Section: 8.3.1 - typo
Issue 8105: Section: 8.3.1
Issue 8107: Section: 9.20.2
Issue 8108: Section: 9.3.1
Issue 8109: Section: 9.3.2
Issue 8110: Section: 9.3.3
Issue 8112: Section: 9.3.5
Issue 8115: Section: 9.3.9
Issue 8116: Section: 9.3.9
Issue 8117: Section: 9.3.10
Issue 8120: Section: 8.3.4
Issue 8127: Section: 9.3.12
Issue 8128: Section: 9.3.13
Issue 8129: Section: 12.3.13
Issue 8130: Section: 12.3.13
Issue 8131: Section: 9.2
Issue 8132: Section: 10.3.1
Issue 8133: Section: 10.3.1
Issue 8134: Section: 10.3.3
Issue 8135: Section: 10.3.4
Issue 8136: Section: 10.3.5
Issue 8137: Section: 10.3.6
Issue 8138: Section: 10.3.8
Issue 8139: Section: 10.3.9
Issue 8140: Section: 10.3.10
Issue 8141: Section: 10.3.11
Issue 8143: Section: 10.4
Issue 8144: Section: 11.1
Issue 8145: Section: 11.3.1
Issue 8146: Section: 11.3.2
Issue 8147: Section: 11.3.3
Issue 8148: Section: 11.3.4
Issue 8149: Section: 11.3.5
Issue 8150: Section: 11.3.6
Issue 8151: Section: 11.3.7
Issue 8152: Section: 11.3.8
Issue 8153: Section: 11.3.9
Issue 8154: Section: 11.3.10
Issue 8156: Section: 11.3.12
Issue 8157: Section: 11.3.13
Issue 8158: Section: 11.3.14
Issue 8159: Section: 11.3.15
Issue 8160: Section: 11.3.16
Issue 8161: Section: 11.3.17
Issue 8162: Section: 11.3.18
Issue 8163: Section: 11.3.19
Issue 8164: Section: 11.3.20
Issue 8165: Section: 11.3.21
Issue 8166: Section: 11.3.22 -- significant revision?
Issue 8167: Section: 11.3.23 -- significant revision?
Issue 8169: Section: 11.3.24
Issue 8170: Section: 11.3.25
Issue 8171: Section: 11.3.26
Issue 8172: Section: 11.3.27
Issue 8173: Section: 11.3.28
Issue 8174: Section: 11.3.29
Issue 8175: Section: 11.3.30
Issue 8176: Section: 11.3.31
Issue 8177: Section: 11.3.33
Issue 8178: Section: 11.3.34
Issue 8180: Section: 11.3.35
Issue 8181: Section: 11.3.36
Issue 8182: Section: 11.3.27
Issue 8183: Section: 11.3.38
Issue 8185: Section: 11.3.40
Issue 8186: Section: 11.3.41
Issue 8187: Section: 11.3.43
Issue 8188: Section: 11.3.44
Issue 8189: Section: 11.3.45
Issue 8190: Section: 11.3.46
Issue 8191: Section: 11.3.47
Issue 8192: Section: 11.3.48
Issue 8193: Section: 11.3.49
Issue 8194: Section: 11.3.50
Issue 8195: Section: 11.3.51
Issue 8196: Section: 11.3.52
Issue 8197: Section: 11.3.42
Issue 8198: Section: 11.3.53
Issue 8199: Section: 11.3.54
Issue 8202: Section: 12.1
Issue 8206: Section: 12.2
Issue 8207: Section: 12.3.2
Issue 8208: Section: 12.3.4
Issue 8209: Section: 12.3.4
Issue 8210: Section: 12.3.5
Issue 8213: Section: 12.3.6
Issue 8214: Section: 12.3.7
Issue 8215: Section: 12.3.8
Issue 8216: Section: 12.1
Issue 8217: Section: 12.3.9
Issue 8218: Section: 12
Issue 8219: Section: 12.3.9
Issue 8220: Section: 12
Issue 8222: Section: 12.3.10
Issue 8223: Section: 12.3.12
Issue 8224: Section: 12.1
Issue 8225: Section: 12.3.13
Issue 8226: MultiplicityElement BNF too restrictive
Issue 8227: Incomplete BNF for Property
Issue 8228: BNF Notation for Operation is too restrictive
Issue 8229: Used of "Redefines ...from Abstractions" in descriptions is misleading
Issue 8232: Section: 12.3.15
Issue 8233: Section: 12.3.16
Issue 8234: Section: 12.3.17
Issue 8235: Section: 12.3.18
Issue 8236: Section: 12.3.19
Issue 8237: Section: 12.3.6 & 12.3.19 Section: 12.3.22
Issue 8238: Section: 12.3.22
Issue 8239: Section: 12.3.24
Issue 8240: Section: 12.3.23
Issue 8241: Section: 12.3.27
Issue 8242: Section: 12.3.28
Issue 8243: Section: 12.3.30
Issue 8245: Section: 12.3.38
Issue 8247: Section: 12.3.31
Issue 8248: Section: 12.3.32
Issue 8250: Section: 12.3.33
Issue 8252: Section: 12.3.34
Issue 8253: Section: 12.3.35
Issue 8254: Section: 12.3
Issue 8255: Section: 12.3.35
Issue 8256: Profiles:Extension End
Issue 8257: Section: 12.3.37
Issue 8258: Section: 12.3.38
Issue 8261: Section: 12.3.41
Issue 8262: Section: 12.3.43
Issue 8263: Section: 12.3.44
Issue 8264: UML 2 Super/templates/inexplicable constraint on defaults
Issue 8265: UML 2 super/templates/
Issue 8270: Section: 12.3.47
Issue 8271: Section: 12.2
Issue 8272: Section: 12.3.48
Issue 8273: Section: 11.3.48
Issue 8275: Section: 12.3.50
Issue 8276: Section: 12.3.51
Issue 8277: Section: 12.3.52
Issue 8279: Section: 12.4
Issue 8280: Section: 12
Issue 8292: Section: 13.1
Issue 8293: Section: 12.3.46
Issue 8294: Section: 12.3.49
Issue 8297: Section: 13.3.3
Issue 8298: Section: 7.3.36
Issue 8301: Section: 13.3.4
Issue 8302: Section: 13.3.7
Issue 8303: Section: 13.3.8
Issue 8304: Section: 13.3.10
Issue 8305: Section: 13.3.9
Issue 8307: Section: 13.3.12
Issue 8308: Section: 13.3.14
Issue 8309: Section: 13.3.15
Issue 8311: Section: 13.3.19
Issue 8312: Section: 13.3.20
Issue 8313: Section: 13.3.22
Issue 8314: Section: 13.3.23
Issue 8315: Section: 13.3.24
Issue 8316: Section: 13.3.26
Issue 8317: Section: 13.3.27
Issue 8318: Section: 13.3.28
Issue 8319: Section: 13.3.29
Issue 8320: Section: 13.3.30
Issue 8322: Section: 13
Issue 8323: Section: 14.3.2
Issue 8324: Section: 14.3.3
Issue 8325: Section: 14.3.4
Issue 8326: Section: 14.3.5
Issue 8327: Section: 14.3.6
Issue 8328: Section: 14.3.8
Issue 8329: Section: 14.3.10
Issue 8330: Section: 14.3.3 & 14.3.11 Section: 14.3.12
Issue 8331: Section: 14.3.12
Issue 8337: Section: 14.3.14
Issue 8338: Section: 14.3.13
Issue 8339: Section: 14.3.15
Issue 8340: Section: 14.3.16
Issue 8341: Section: 14.3.17
Issue 8343: Section: 14.3.19
Issue 8345: Section: 14.3.20
Issue 8346: Section: 14.3.21
Issue 8347: Section: 14.3.21
Issue 8348: Section: 14.3.24
Issue 8349: Section: 14.3.25
Issue 8350: Section: 14.3.26
Issue 8351: Section: 14.3.29
Issue 8352: Section: 14.4
Issue 8356: Section: 11.3.5
Issue 8357: Section: 12.3.4
Issue 8401: Section: 15.3.1
Issue 8402: Section: 15.3.2
Issue 8403: Section: 15.3.3
Issue 8404: Section: 15.3.5
Issue 8405: Section: 15.3.5
Issue 8406: Section: 11.3.42
Issue 8407: Section: 15.3.6
Issue 8408: Section: 15.3.7
Issue 8409: Section: 15.3.8
Issue 8410: Section: 15.3.9
Issue 8411: Section: 15.3.10
Issue 8412: Specification: Action Semantics Section: 9.5
Issue 8413: Action Semantics Section: 9.5
Issue 8415: Section: 15.3.11
Issue 8416: Section: 15.3.11
Issue 8433: Section: 15.3.12
Issue 8439: Appendix C.1
Issue 8440: Section: Appendix A
Issue 8443: Section: 15.3.14
Issue 8444: Section: 15.3.15
Issue 8445: Section: 15.3.16
Issue 8446: Section: 15.3.7
Issue 8449: Should Profiles::Image be an Element?
Issue 8451: OCL for Property::opposite() is incorrect:
Issue 8452: Remove redundant superclass for Element
Issue 8453: Profiles::ExtensionEnd has wrong default multiplicity
Issue 8454: Profiles::ObjectNode has wrong default multiplicity
Issue 8455: Profiles::ObjectNode has wrong default multiplicity
Issue 8456: UML 2 Super / Collaborations / improper subset
Issue 8457: UML 2 Super / General / improper subsetting
Issue 8458: UML 2 Super / General / missing merges
Issue 8459: UML 2 Super / Conformance / inconsistencies
Issue 8461: UML 2 Super / Kernel / excessive restriction on redefinition
Issue 8462: UML 2 Super / General / invalid subset rule too strict
Issue 8463: UML 2 Super / Common Behaviors / missing multiplicites
Issue 8465: Section: 16.3.3
Issue 8466: Section: 16.3.4
Issue 8467: Section: 16.3.5
Issue 8468: Section: 16.3.6
Issue 8469: Section: 14.3.3
Issue 8476: Section: Common Behavior
Issue 8477: Section: Actions
Issue 8478: ValueSpecificationAction, Attribute section, is missing the return pin
Issue 8481: Section: Activities
Issue 8482: Section: Activities, ExpansionRegion
Issue 8483: Section: Activities, ExpansionRegion (02)
Issue 8484: Section: Activities, ExpansionRegion (03)
Issue 8485: Section: Activities, ExpansionRegion (04)
Issue 8486: Section: Activities, ExpansionRegion (05)
Issue 8487: ExpansionRegioin example, Figure 261: concurrent => parallel Expansion region description
Issue 8488: Expansion region description
Issue 8490: Section: Activities
Issue 8491: Add constraint in LoopNode
Issue 8493: Semantics of isAssured/isDeterminant in conditional node
Issue 8496: Add constraints on conditional and loop nodes
Issue 8497: Add constraints on conditional and loop nodes (02)
Issue 8499: No notation
Issue 8500: mustIsolate:
Issue 8502: Figure 209 of Activites
Issue 8503: Clarify the semantics of minimum multiplicity > 0 for streaming parameters Remove FTF comments
Issue 8506: Section: 17.2.1
Issue 8507: Section: 17.2.2
Issue 8508: Section: 17.3.1
Issue 8509: Section: 17.4
Issue 8510: Section: 17.5.1
Issue 8511: Section: 17.5.2
Issue 8512: Section: 17.5.1
Issue 8513: Section: 17.5.3
Issue 8514: Section: 17.5.3
Issue 8515: Section: 17.5.4
Issue 8516: Section: 17.5.5
Issue 8517: Section: 17.5.6
Issue 8518: Section: 17.1
Issue 8527: Section: 17.5.7
Issue 8528: Section: 17.5.8
Issue 8529: Section: 17.5.12
Issue 8530: Section: 17.5.13
Issue 8544: Section: 12 Activities
Issue 8587: Section: 17.5.14
Issue 8588: Section: 17.5.15
Issue 8589: Section: 17.5.16
Issue 8590: Section: 17.5.17
Issue 8591: Section: 17.5.18
Issue 8592: Section: 17.5.19
Issue 8593: Section: 17.5.20
Issue 8595: Section: 18.1.2
Issue 8596: Section: 18.3.2
Issue 8598: Section: 18.2
Issue 8599: Section: 18.3.2
Issue 8600: Section: 18.3.3
Issue 8602: Section: 18.3.7
Issue 8603: Section: 18.3.8
Issue 8604: Section: 18.4
Issue 8605: Section: 18
Issue 8606: Section: Appendix B
Issue 8607: Section: Appendix B (02)
Issue 8608: Section: Appendix C Table 25
Issue 8609: Section: Appendix C Table 26
Issue 8610: Section: Appendix C Table 27
Issue 8611: Section: 15.3.8
Issue 8613: Section: D.1
Issue 8614: Section: D.2
Issue 8615: Section: D.3
Issue 8617: Section: E.1
Issue 8619: Section: Appendix F
Issue 8670: Section: 12
Issue 8672: Section 12 (03)
Issue 8674: text p.297
Issue 8675: Output tokens
Issue 8676: output tokens (02)
Issue 8677: token movement
Issue 8678: UML 2 -- Need explanations of XMI structure and usage
Issue 8679: token
Issue 8680: Section: 12
Issue 8681: add the rule of ``natural termination''
Issue 8683: ``conditional node or conditional node'' delete one.
Issue 8685: Delete sentence
Issue 8690: Section: 12.2
Issue 8696: policy to describe the Associations sub section of a meta class description
Issue 8706: Profile Semantics, pag 723
Issue 8718: In Activities, Figure 176, Action should be abstract
Issue 8719: Semantics for instances applies to InstanceSpecification?
Issue 8720: String is primitive but has structure.
Issue 8728: Solid triange notation for Association
Issue 8729: Multiple exception handlers
Issue 8730: Exceptions thrown across synchronous invocations
Issue 8732: In Figure 210, put merge before Use Part to merge the incoming flows
Issue 8733: LoopNode should move rather than copy values to/from loop variables
Issue 8734: Clarify first constraint on InputPin and OutputPin, move "only" to before "
Issue 8735: The Syle Guidelines for Stereotype
Issue 8736: Actions, CallBehaviorAction, third sentence,
Issue 8737: ControlFlow
Issue 8739: ExpansionRegion
Issue 8740: ConditionalNode and LoopNode test and bodies should be ExecutableNodes
Issue 8745: Section: Interactions
Issue 8746: Clarify caption of Figure 56
Issue 8749: ParameterSet, first line: "inputs *or* outputs".
Issue 8752: Last element in transition BNF
Issue 8753: Page: 591
Issue 8759: OpaqueAction
Issue 8766: Section: 12.3.37
Issue 8769: Can't specify mutator semantics for derived properties
Issue 8770: Section: Actions
Issue 8772: Section: 11.3.48
Issue 8781: Actions should be able to overlap